Comments 994

Re: Soapbox: Gears Of War 2 Deserves 'The Last Of Us' Style Remake

Grumblevolcano

I'd prefer a MCC style collection, the multiplayer experience of the 360 games are either only finding bots or you come across a load of cheaters that warp all over the place with infinite ammo and much faster than usual fire rate. A MCC style collection would allow PC players to experience the campaigns and allow Xbox players to relive the multiplayer.

Re: Xbox's Matt Booty Is 'Excited' To Show The New Fable Game

Grumblevolcano

I really liked how there was only a small gap between announcement and release for Forza Horizon games (it was always announce at E3, release in Fall/Holiday the same year). While Fable has been announced for over 2 years at this point, it would be cool if the re-reveal to launch cycle was close to the FH cycle.

Re: Xbox's 'Approach' With Starfield Is Leading To More ActiBlizz Scrutiny

Grumblevolcano

@EvilSilentFrame Not exactly lie but they did use smoke and mirrors on the whole "legacy" thing. The way it was worded strongly suggested that games like Elder Scrolls 6 and Fallout 5 would be coming to PS because the franchises have a legacy there but that's not the case.

That's what Phil Spencer is doing regarding these acquisition statements, where the most common interpretation of the statements are something that benefits all platforms but you look a lot deeper and the actual meaning is something which only benefits Xbox. For example, what he means regarding still releasing CoD on Playstation is likely that the FTP multiplayer experience releases on Playstation but the single player campaigns are only on platforms which have Game Pass.

It's good that a regulatory body is finally calling Microsoft out on these smoke and mirror attempts.

Re: id Software Says It's Hard At Work On Its 'Next Big Game'

Grumblevolcano

@Richnj I agree it didn't need to compete with CoD, I was looking more that from 2015 onwards CoD was the shooter franchise for Playstation but if Killzone/Resistance/SOCOM stayed CoD would've been a shooter franchise for Playstation (still the biggest but just an option).

It's like how there'd still be plenty of people who would buy Nintendo hardware for JRPGs like Xenoblade and Fire Emblem even if the Pokemon franchise ended with Scarlet/Violet.

Re: id Software Says It's Hard At Work On Its 'Next Big Game'

Grumblevolcano

@Richnj CoD is easily to blame for the end of Killzone, Resistance and SOCOM. Sony got the CoD marketing and timed exclusivity deal in 2015 then following that they released 0 FPS/TPS games.

Sony's right when they say CoD is in a league of its own but they are to blame for that. What Sony did was the equivalent of if Microsoft killed off franchises like Halo and Gears in 2009.

Re: Talking Point: What's Your 2022 Game Of The Year So Far?

Grumblevolcano

I've only bought FF Origin and Sonic Origins this year so far on Xbox so I'll go for FF Origin. If DLC expansions counts then FH5 Hot Wheels for sure.

Across all platforms, top 3 so far would probably be:
1. Xenoblade Chronicles 3
2. Fire Emblem Warriors Three Hopes
3. Portal Companion Collection

Switch this year is insanely good.

Re: PSA: Deathloop Could Potentially Hit Xbox Game Pass In Under A Month

Grumblevolcano

I don't think it'll be shadow drop, September has Grounded and Microsoft seems to want to aim for that 1 1st party release a month release setup. I'm leaning towards early December.

July - As Dusk Falls + Hot Wheels DLC
August - ?
September - Grounded
October - ?
November - Pentiment + Halo Infinite Season 3
December - ?

It can't be August because of the exclusivity deal and October would be rather busy for Xbox if the acquisition passes by then so they'd probably save Deathloop for December along with FH5 expansion 2.

Re: Xbox Game Pass Is Hurting Right Now, But Larger Forces Are At Play

Grumblevolcano

Xbox in general has been rough since April, not just Game Pass. Like big showcases usually act as a beacon of hope for a platform but the Xbox Showcase in June felt very off and the Gamescom lineup also seems off. Makes me think that Microsoft are heavily relying on the Activision acquisition going through sooner rather than later to get a massive quantity of games added to Game Pass in one drop. It wouldn't improve my opinion of Xbox but it would for others.

Re: Xbox Accuses Sony Of 'Paying' To Block Games From Game Pass

Grumblevolcano

@Rangers420 Unfortunately Microsoft is too busy buying up everything instead of improving what they already have. I'd absolutely rather have had a situation where Halo Infinite was the best Halo game and MCC didn't have microtransactions than the outcome where Halo is killed off because buying Activision gives Microsoft CoD for example.

Re: Halo Infinite's Forge Mode Will Be A Game Changer, According To 343

Grumblevolcano

@themightyant I think the biggest benefit Forge will give for the general player is more maps. Instead of 2 maps every 6 months we'll likely see a load of player created maps from Forge added into the multiplayer matchmaking rotation. Forge would create other benefits as well but not if there isn't a custom games browser launching alongside it and we've heard nothing about that.

Re: Xbox To Host Gamescom 2022 Livestream Later This Month

Grumblevolcano

@themightyant Nintendo has the best approach:

  • February: Focus on February - August, tease a few games that are further out
  • June: Focus on June - December, tease a few games that are further out
  • September: Focus on September - March, tease a few games that are further out

Further out shouldn't be years away though, stuff like the reveal of Metroid Prime 4 at E3 2017 and Bayonetta 3 at Game Awards 2017 were way too far in advance. Stuff like Bayonetta 3 reappearing in the September 2021 Direct is better fit (the game releases in October 2022) for "further out".

Re: Talking Point: How Would You Compare The New PS Plus To Xbox Game Pass?

Grumblevolcano

PS+ Essential is a lot better than Games With Gold and with 360 games ending in October, Games With Gold will be even worse.

As for Game Pass, PS+ Extra and PS+ Premium I'd say PS+ Extra is the best of the bunch currently. Game Pass has been on the weaker side since April meanwhile PS+ Extra has been strong since its start in June.

PS+ Premium is the weakest of the bunch given the classic games collection is very limited and the PS3 games should be native. Also currently (though will be fixed in the future) there's the PAL mess for subscribers in regions like Europe that used to have PAL

Re: Soapbox: Forza Horizon Is Spinning Its Wheels, So Let's Bring Back The Best Racer On Xbox

Grumblevolcano

While FH5 is a good game (and Hot Wheels is a good expansion), I agree that something felt off about FH5 but I'd say the same about FH4. I think it's down to the live service push, both FH4 and FH5's focus is the Festival Playlist (i.e. complete tasks every week to unlock new collectibles) meanwhile FH3 was centralized around the story campaign.

That live service push is the way a lot of Microsoft's games have turned towards like people don't even play the objective in Halo Infinite because they have challenges to unlock which involves killing with a specific weapon.

Re: The Exciting Prospect Of ActiBlizz On Xbox Game Pass Is Starting To Feel Real

Grumblevolcano

I wonder if Microsoft will consider bringing back the backwards compatibility program. The vast majority of backwards compatibility Activision games are CoD (OG Xbox and 360 era Activision was so much more than just CoD unlike nowadays) but perhaps with the acquisition it'll make adding non-CoD easier.

Have another big batch of games including non-CoD Activision games and more non-Activision games alongside it.

Otherwise the big Game Pass drop after the acquisition is going to be like 20 CoD games and 6 non-CoD games which wouldn't be a good look on Xbox.

Still don't care about Activision games but the idea of backwards compatibility possibly returning is exciting.

Re: It Might Be A Mistake, But Far Cry 6 Is Being Advertised For Xbox Game Pass

Grumblevolcano

@Bleachedsmiles Given 1st party is the only thing Microsoft can truly control, Phil Spencer is likely referring to the 1st party lineup in that comment. Their original schedule was probably similar structure to last year, something like:

  • 1st half of 2022 - Goldeneye
  • July - As Dusk Falls
  • August - Redfall
  • September - Grounded (leaving early access), Deathloop
  • October - Pentiment, Forza Motorsport
  • November - Starfield

Re: Aaron Greenberg Teases 'A Lot More' Unannounced Xbox Games In The Works

Grumblevolcano

@BAMozzy For Nintendo, the 1st party lineup for the same time period (E3 2021 to what would've been E3 2022) was:

  • Game Builder Garage (June 11th 2021)
  • Mario Golf Super Rush (June 25th 2021)
  • Skyward Sword HD (July 16th 2021)
  • WarioWare Get It Together (September 10th 2021)
  • Metroid Dread (October 8th 2021)
  • Mario Party Superstars (October 29th 2021)
  • Pokemon Brilliant Diamond/Shining Pearl (November 19th 2021)
  • Big Brain Academy Brain vs. Brain (December 3rd 2021)
  • Pokemon Legends Arceus (January 28th 2022)
  • Kirby and the Forgotten Land (March 25th 2022)
  • Switch Sports (April 29th 2022)
  • Mario Strikers Battle League (June 10th 2022)

With 3rd party exclusives such as Shin Megami Tensei V and Triangle Strategy supporting it.

Switch definitely has the much more consistent 1st party lineup of the three by far and this has been the case for most of its lifespan. But if you want to play 3rd party multiplatform games, you're better off with PS5, Series X or PC/Steam Deck as a lot of 3rd party stuff skips the Switch so it balances out.

Re: Five Years Later, Game Pass Is Still Growing Alongside Xbox Game Studios

Grumblevolcano

@Royalblues Jim Ryan's made it clear that live service is the future he plans to take PS. For example 12 live service games for 2022 - 2024 is a lot (only 1 has happened so far (MLB The Show 22), for some reason he doesn't count GT7 as live service when it clearly is).

I'd guess stuff like GoW Ragnarok, Spider-Man 2 and Wolverine are games that were greenlighted before Jim Ryan took over and the big AAA blockbusters PS is loved for will eventually disappear.

Re: After The Xbox Showcase, Game Pass Is Looking Stacked In 2023

Grumblevolcano

@Cherip-the-Ripper Deathloop and Ghostwire Tokyo both have 1 year exclusivity but the absence of both in the showcase makes it seem like Microsoft can't talk about Xbox version until the exclusivity is over (September 14th 2022 and March 25th 2023 respectively) so there'll probably be a bit of a gap between the exclusivity ending and the Xbox release (I'd guess October 2022 for Deathloop for example).