Just thinking back to Gears of War 2 hits me with a huge wave of nostalgia. Epic Games' follow-up to the revolutionary Gears of War launched right around the time I picked up an Xbox 360, and it certainly wasn't a bad introduction to what the system could do. In fact, almost 15 years on and this is still, for my money, the very best Gears of War campaign to date, and while it looks great to this day thanks to Xbox's backwards compatible enhancements, I think this is one 360 exclusive that deserves a full remake.
That is, in part, because Gears 2 is in a weird spot in 2022. On the one hand, the title looks and plays better than ever thanks to a recent FPS Boost update, bringing things to 60FPS. However, with Gears of War getting a remake in 2015, and Gears of War 3 feeling much more modern after its own back compat enhancements, Gears 2 really does feel like it's ready for an overhaul in comparison. The Last of Us Part I is making me want that even more.
I'll be clear here, The Last of Us didn't need a remake. The game's PS4 remaster is still a looker, not to mention the PS3 original isn't even 10 years old yet. However, I can't dispute just how bloody gorgeous the remake looks, especially when it comes to facial animations, character performances, and big set pieces. These areas are where the older Gears games suffer (like a lot of early 360-era stuff) and I'd love to see this story presented in a similarly modern fashion to TLOU Part 1. Full-scale remakes aren't usually what Xbox does, but I'd take an exemption to the rule for this one.
Gears of War 2 ramped its campaign right up to the max as well. Coming off the dark, atmospheric, and at times, creepy vibe of the original, Gears 2 felt like a full-scale war. The Locust came out swinging after the events of the first game, and it led to some truly incredible set pieces in the sequel. Exploring half sunken cities? Check. Riding a 'Brumak' to destroy waves of Locust drones? Check. Cutting through the arteries of a giant worm? Err, check. These battles would be incredible to re-live through the power of Xbox Series X and S, and we'd argue that a Gears 2 remaster would make the whole series feel pretty modern in 2022.
Some of my favourite Gears 2 memories do lie in the quiet moments that harkened back to the first game too, so it's not only cutscenes and set piece moments that'd benefit from a remake. The whole sequence where you're being led through a dark, abandoned facility by the haywire AI 'Niles' is a particular highlight, and we're already imagining a fresh run through the New Hope Research Facility with all the Unreal Engine 5 bells and whistles.
What The Coalition has delivered with the modern Gears games, on a technical level, would excite us even more should such a project come to fruition. Using Unreal Engine 4, Gears of War 4 and Gears 5 look and play phenomenally well, even if they do miss some of the character of the original trilogy. A fusing of said character with The Coalition & UE5 though? Sign me the hell up.
Next year, Gears of War 2 hits 15 years of age, which feels like the right time to me to unleash such a remake. We've heard rumours before about a Marcus Fenix Collection that haven't yet to come to pass, but truth be told, a Gears 2 remake is all I believe we really need. I'm still clinging on to this vaguely-connected tweet (that happens to contain modern-looking Gears 2 artwork) in the hope that one day soon, we get to re-visit the Locust Hollow with all that glorious next-gen goodness.
But, what do you think? Should a Gears of War 2 remake happen? Vote in the poll and let us know!
Comments 49
A lot of games deserve a The Last of Us style remake, on all 3 platforms, both first party and third party.
You know which game definitely didn’t deserve one? The Last of Us. That game can fool people into thinking it’s current gen. Both the ps3 and ps4 version IMO.
Eitherway I’d love the uncharted trilogy, halo trilogy, zelda ocarins of time, the infamous games, gears of war and metroid prime 1 to get remakes like these.
TLOU style remake = a remaster. Agree.
They just better not try to charge $60 for it (yea that is imo too much, even if I have Game Pass.)
What the hell is up with everyone and remakes etc.
Please all resources on new games and new IPs.
Can’t we just get over the old games and have some new ones.
Sometimes I wonder what the point of this new generation was. The new £450/£480 machines have hardly been tested in power after two years.
Don’t encourage more of this remake/remaster.
By the way my comment above.
I am massive gears of war admirer, played everyone on day one.
So it is nothing against gears of war, one of my favourite IPs of all time.
@Dezzy70 Because new games are all live-service GaaS stuff. We keep looking back to the good'ol days for fantastic AAA single player experiences, sadly more so on Xbox.
@BrilliantBill
Well they should make new AAA single player game experiences.
The other side do and seem to be doing extremely well on that front at the moment.
Two big ones this year HFW and GOWR and I guess even GT7.
They can even afford to put prices of their games and console up and still outsell xbox.
Fed up of remakes and remasters BUT I’d play the original Gears of War trilogy again with a full makeover.
1 and 2 are 2 of the best, most memorable games I’ve ever played, I love them. Gears of War Ultimate imo did not do the original justice, the AI was broken and it looks old already. Remake, remaster, Re whatever the 3 of them I say.
Great energy article over on NINTENDO LIFE.
Not only is the PS5 the most expensive console to buy now UK etc.
It is the most expensive to play £1.43 per 2 hours play of electricity.
Series x £1.09 per 2 hours play.
Please no more remaster/Remake garbage
@Chaudy
Thank you.
Bring on the Marcus Fenix collection..
I love Gears of War 2, so a shinier version would be most welcome. I was quite disappointed they didn’t do it right after finishing the remaster of the first one.
I didn’t much like Gears 3 or 4 (so I didn’t bother with 5), but a new version of Gears 2 would definitely be up my alley.
@Dezzy70
Saw the headline and thought: Dezzy is gonna have a field day with this 😜 Well, I guess it depends. While I get why many people are fed up with remakes, some of them are just up your alley. In my case that's The Last of Us. However, somewhere around Halloween I intend to replay Dead Space and have no intention of buying the remake. Same with RDR, if it ever happens as many fans want it. I agree with @BrilliantBill though. I look for great gaming experiences in the past, rather than the present. You are a fan of Sony's first party games, but just wait for all those GaaS that are inbound. Those will take a toll on the number of great Sony single player games.
Please no more remakes or remasters. Enough is enough
@gollumb82
Me not into remakes or remasters. 😂
I have played last of us on the original PS3.
Definitely won’t be double dipping on the PS5, even it was a free upgrade and not the extortionate £70 for a remake.
@gollumb82
I’m also a massive fan of Xbox first party games.
That is why I go mad at them for not giving me any on the AAA front for my series x.
Me and Xbox were a perfect match in the Xbox360 days and even some of the Xbox one days.
@SplooshDmg @Dezzy70
Touche! Haha. As much as I like to go back in time to enjoy oldies but goldies, I am anxious for Xbox to start rolling out those heavy-hitters. Can't wait for Starfield, Hellblade 2, Forza 8, Avowed, The Outer Worlds 2, Stalker etc
I'd prefer a MCC style collection, the multiplayer experience of the 360 games are either only finding bots or you come across a load of cheaters that warp all over the place with infinite ammo and much faster than usual fire rate. A MCC style collection would allow PC players to experience the campaigns and allow Xbox players to relive the multiplayer.
@SplooshDmg
Yes it is true I am impatient, I’m the same at work and in life 😂
new IP please
Being honest for me even though I am impatient
It’s more Xbox putting faith back in their brand for me.
I’m waiting for the big three FM, Redfall and Starfield AAA to release before June 2023 as per Xbox showcase.
If they do and they are of very good AAA quality all round then I will stay with Xbox. If it strays a little from that then I will stay with Xbox.
If they stray far from that, release dates and AAA quality wise, then that will probably be my lot for Xbox and my Game Pass.
I will cash in 😊 and stick with me PS5 and Switch.
Shame as I have been with Xbox since day, every console.
@SplooshDmg
Agreed. I even sold my launch XSX out of frustration like 8 months ago, but the Starfield trailer made me reconsider. I'm willing to wait patiently now. The Bethesda deal helped a lot as I haven't played any Arcane games yet, so I have some catching up to do. I'm hoping the ActiBlizz deal will further help us make it through the exclusives drought.
@Dezzy70
In other words, as far as Xbox goes, you've been Livin on a prayer 😁 Like most Xbox faithful, I imagine. I'm in the same boat- hoping for the best, but prepared for the worst (got a PS5, Switch and a Vita).
@gollumb82
If you have noticed on here over the this year I got angry and very frustrated but know I am more calm.
The reason I have stopped caring about Xbox even with all my gaming history I have with them since day one, original Xbox.
If the company can’t provided me with my gaming needs I like, new top end AAA titles like the other Xbox consoles did then I will slowly stop caring like now and then end up leaving them.
That is fine companies change and change direction, but hey let’s wait and see until June 2023. I hope they do it and keep me with them I really do.
An overpriced remake that barely improves the game design of the original? No thanks.
Probably doesn't help that Gears 2 kind of killed my interest in the series. I vastly preferred the more restrained and atmospheric approach of the original.
“ But, what do you think? Should a Gears of War 2 remake happen? “
Yeah why not, I would also like Microsoft to slap a £70 price tag to really satisfy the nostalgic feeling. And to really scratch the itch, follow Sony’s lead and don’t release it on the subscription service (Game Pass in this case) 😉
....slow news day or PushSquare freelance journalism, which is it?😜
@SplooshDmg
That made me chuckle. I agree with you regarding Bethesda. People like to put their games down due to bugs and such, but I really liked the fact they didn't let Fallout rot. Loved New Vegas (even though it was made by Obsidian, but Bethesda provided the blueprint), really liked Fallout 4. Haven't played Dishonored and I love Thief so I think I'll like it. Same with Prey (huge Bioshock and System Shock fan here). If only Bethesda makes good on giving us great new games, that alone will be a lot. Like you I can't wait for Starfield. Should make me forget about other games for a while. Problem is there's a lot riding on this game. If it fails, I think many people will lose their faith in MS and Xbox. Me included.
@Sol4ris I think remakes can only be happening if you have some new titles too.
Much as I liked Gears2, its time for Microsoft to create the future and not dwell on the past. Im looking forward to MS finally jumping into next gen next year.... They have many talanted teams now, so much as I worry about their ability to manage effectively, teams like ID will pdoduce the goods regardless. Bring it on.... Please!
@jcboyer515 I didn’t say it’s a gen 9 game performance wise.
The artstyle and graphical style could fool people into thinking it’s current gen. Any screenshot basically.
Let’s see this was a free upgrade that just made the ps3 game native 4K and 120fps People that never played it would’ve thought it was a brand new, albeit lower end, ps5 or XSX game.
Hope that example works better.
Gun to my head, the first game that comes to mind would be Bully. But I don't think the way the game approached certain topics would not have aged well with the times.
But I agree with some of the sentiments here about enough of remakes/remasters. Tbh even done with sequels, just give us some new IP and looking at the announced games, seems that Team Green has more new IPs coming out. Of course comparing the two platforms since those are the two I play on.
@Dezzy70 I'm getting sick of this remake/remaster trend that's been going on for years. The only games I can think of that benefited of it were Demon's Souls PS5 and Gears of War Ultimate Edition which actually improved on them, unlike Resident Evil 3 remake which has less content than the original game.
At this rate Resident Evil 14 and it's remake will both be released on the same day.
@darkswabber for comparison I booted up TLOU remastered after a stint on the remake and honestly, the remake feels far better than the screenshots etc make it look. Don't get me wrong, it isn't worth £70 (I only went for it as I've got a bunch of vouchers and my wife is away for a few days so had a hankering for a game I could get fully immersed in), but I honestly would dispute it being a remaster - you can tell they've gone further than just up-rezzing it. Probably a bit between remaster and a remake.
As for Gears 2, as it would undoubtedly be on gamepass I would give it a go, as I've never played it before. But then ago, I found Gears 4 and 5 impossibly dull, so maybe they're not really for me
@Dezzy70 I think you're a bit mixed up there. Looking at the article it says PS5 is £1.43 per week, not per hour (based on the assumption of 2 hours playtime per day). Series X is £1.09.
@PapaGlitch
I thought I had messed up
Then you look on another website and says different.
Oh well.
Xbox’s game development is ungodly slow as it is, not sure we want to further pushback new games. Sony has the Talent to work on a new game and updating an old one, xbox seems to struggle with the former as it is
@Solidchief
It is getting a bit much now we nearly two years into the new generation.
Also still getting cross generation games.
Well all being good we will have
FM, Redfall & Starfield no later than June 2023
All new generation only I think.
Unfortunately and me included if they are all new generation only, we shall be expecting the overall effects and graphics etc to look better than any current or new cross generation games or do something a bit special and new generation.
Now not being a party pooper, but maybe FM.
But the other two won’t be at FM or FH5 or HFW or GOWR standard to look at for sure.
It’s a very slow and lingering new generation for me, even more so on my series x.
@Solidchief
Also when new big AAA games used to get delayed when they did eventually release they were so worth the wait and had that AAA quality all round.
I respect Microsoft for the delay on the big three AAA into the first half of next year 2023.
Fine but let’s when they do release have something worth the wait and top end AAA and something a bit special as all three are new generation only.
But I could almost bet my life one FM might be, but the other 2 Starfield won’t and neither will Redfall. Doesn’t mean they won’t be good games but after AAA games get delays I expect it to be worth the wait. We looking at you Halo Infinite.
Should have a collection of all 3 original games (didn't like judgement because it didn't feel like a proper gears of war game & felt more cartoony)
@Dezzy70 This had to be the worst year for Xbox when there's literally no first party exclusives whatsoever. I'm glad the games are becoming Series X/S gen only but Xbox seriously need to do something with their studios, be a bit more strict instead of being completely hands offs.
The Halo IP needs to be given to another studio since 343 can't even add features like co-op and forge that were in the other games day one.
Nope it doesn't ...not yet
@Dezzy70 If Starfield, Redfall & Forza Motorsport don't get delayed it will be a very good start of the year for Xbox. Plus we'll be getting Ghostwire Tokyo, Stalker 2, Diablo IV and maybe Activision games will be on GamePass if the the deal finalises next year.
@Solidchief
Not sure where they are on studio management and the structure and how they approach project management, micro management and project milestones, aims and objectives and completion.
Big Phil might be taking the hand off approach but normally in management it has to come from the top down, so that is Phil and driven through your management team.
Phil maybe a gamer etc and nice guy, but that doesn’t mean he is a good project and team manager.
So far not great but time will time in the first six months of next year 2023, the make or break 6 months for and me Xbox, after being with them since day one original Xbox.
@Solidchief
Well Starfield and Redfall have already been delayed and Xbox said we will get them and FM in the first 6 months of next year 2023 after their dopey showcase the next 12 months PR.
For I don’t give a dam about game pass and old games be it Activision or not.
I get a new generation console for new big AAA games not to play old ones I have already played that I wanted to play on the original consoles.
This is Xbox and game pass biggest problem they need to get new AAA games out like spread through out the year like a drum beat and like Sony and Nintendo normally due.
It’s so hard to see the system they need to take as the other two are more successful and popular than Xbox worldwide and easily have more momentum.
Xbox thought game pass would give them the edge so far it hasn’t at all and they are still limping along in third place.
One day they will learn you can create other goals, mess around with the way you go about it, hide behind other statistics but games and dam good ones AAA sell consoles and create enthusiasm in the public eye and product momentum.
Also good PR is required.
@Dezzy70 You ain't wrong about them relying on Game Pass. They definitely do need to have exclusives spread throughout the entire year instead of leaving it to the end of the year, like they did in 2021 and were going to do it again this year with Starfield and Redfall.
The only games that should be considered are ones not playable on current hardware. I’d love to play Vampire the Masquerade: Bloodlines or the original Deus Ex on Xbox.
I have a wacky idea for all developers. How about making an entirely new game?
The good thing is that it’d be on Game Pass and not $70/€80…
Why do we need all these remakes? If you want to polish up a game through an update/patch go for it. But completely remaking a game and charging €60 seems stupid to me.
Naw but Battlefield does.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...