Comments 950

Re: Braid: Anniversary Edition 'Sold Like Dogs**t', Says Creator

pip_muzz

The guy is an idiot. In the same interview he states it still sold more than Digital Eclipse's Atari 50 games and gold master series. Games which had significantly more content than this "anniversary edition" and he still complains!? Braid is an amazing game but this Jonathan Blow... What a *

Re: Halo TV Show Cancelled By Paramount+ After Two Seasons

pip_muzz

Season 2 was genuinely good. The problem is it's clearly a very expensive TV show to make. Almost certainly costing a lot more than Fallout, Last of Us etc... Halo on the cheap just doesn't work. Would be surprised if someone picks it up elsewhere.
That said, new viewers should skip season 1 and just enjoy the fall of reach!

Re: Reaction: Xbox's Push Towards 'Microsoft Gaming' Looks More Drastic Than We First Thought

pip_muzz

Xbox bought Activision, not to change the Call of Duty machine, but to simply absorb it.
It's abundantly clear that more companies will be folded into the so called "blockbuster" titles and all the (in my view oft overlooked) interesting games like Pentiment, Grounded, Hi Fi Rush etc... will be ignored in favour of the COD cashcow.
I'd honestly rather have Don Mattrick back at this point.

Re: Xbox Fans React Angrily To Closure Of Bethesda's Tango Gameworks

pip_muzz

It's not acceptable to buy new studios with the intention of closing old ones. It's no coincidence that the ladder was pulled up after they just released two games recently. MS not willing to fund the development of new ones is crystal clear in its short-sightedness. Angry is a very polite way to put how I feel about MS right now.....

Re: Hi-Fi RUSH Is One Of PS5's Best-Rated Games Of 2024 So Far

pip_muzz

The difference in score is just the "Xbox tax". For some reason only Xbox games get reviewed with the "gaming climate" as a thing. Also some of the negative reviews at launch were genuine clickbait nonsense. Now the game has been out over a year it's generally the more respectable gaming sites reviewing the PS version, hence the higher score for exactly the same game.

Re: Xbox Reminds Fans 'More Than 10 Major Releases' Are On The Way

pip_muzz

The 10 2024 releases:

1) Hellblade 2 Senua's Saga
2) Towerborne
3) Flight Simulator 24
4) Avowed
5) Ara History Untold
6) Indiana Jones and the Great Circle
7) Call of Duty: Gulf War
8) Diablo 4 expansion?
9) Starfield Shattered Space expansion?
10) ?

Definitely the claim of 10 games this year from Xbox adds up!

Re: Talking Point: Are You Still Playing Forza Motorsport On Xbox Game Pass?

pip_muzz

It's a real transitional experience. The driving and handling is the best out there, better than GT7 for my money. But the single player experience is so stale and lacking, add in fundamental problems like the AI and penalty system and it just needs real work still.
I do believe the quality driving mechanics make it worthwhile for racing fans but as it stands, maybe wait to reinstall until the larger problems are fixed.

Re: Poll: How Would You Grade The Xbox Developer Direct 2024?

pip_muzz

B for me. Hellblade 2 looks great with a release date soon. Avowed shaping up nicely. Indiana Jones looks perfect.
But Ara not coming to console is a shame and Visions of Mana just felt like filler. Not an MS Studios game and not even coming to Game Pass!
But the good outweighs the bad.

Re: Talking Point: Do You Like The 'Modern' Assassin's Creed Games?

pip_muzz

Played AC Origins and ended up having to play AC 2 parallel at the same time. For all the world building and fun, the games just do too much for the player automatically. Systematic problem of modern games. Difficulty doesn't change the fact that core gameplay mechanics are far too simplified (in Origins case, just climbing any surface without issue!)

Re: In The End, Are You Happy With Xbox's First-Party Lineup For 2023?

pip_muzz

Also worth pointing out that the Xbox console ports of Age of Empires 2+4, GoldenEye 007 & Quake 2 arrived this year as well from a first party perspective!
Add those into the list and it's a very good year indeed!
(Not forgetting the Rally Adventure Expansion for Forza Horizon 5 and the fact Halo Infinite is finally in a good state)

Re: Halo TV Show's Season 2 Poster Has Already Been Photoshopped

pip_muzz

@BIG3 if you know nothing about Halo it's probably worth a watch. I watched Season 1 with my wife (who is not a gamer) and she found it ok, if rather disjointed. As a big fan of the games it irritated me, it was clearly written and made by people who have next to no interest in the source material.

Re: Talking Point: Overall, How Successful Has 2023 Been For Xbox?

pip_muzz

I gave a B, but harsher scores are also fair. It's a problem of Xbox's own making in that 2023 had such huge expectations, it could never meet them all. Making the obvious disappointments like Redfall stand out all the more.
I am one in the crowd that think Starfield is amazing, but Forza Motorsport is seriously needing a lot of work still...
Hi-Fi Rush my game of the year. Having Age of Empires 2+4 along with Goldeneye on consoles is also amazing! Not to mention the Quake 2 re-release.
But then Minecraft Legends was poor...
On a normal timeframe it's a very good year but coming off the back of the worst Xbox year ever in 2022, I can't help but feel they needed just a little bit more.

Re: Turn 10 Doubles Down On Bringing 'Monthly New Content' To Forza Motorsport

pip_muzz

Again, the AI is absolutely atrocious.
The penalty system is ridiculous too. I praise the attempt to have online clean racing, but when I get rammed in a hairpin, bounce into another car and get a 2+ second penalty, the system is broken.

That's the problem. Online has a ridiculous penalty system, even with an A safety rating (avoid a collision, oooops off track that's a penalty)
Single Player has awful AI.

I'd be much more forgiving but I really can't work out how this took 6 years....

Re: Talking Point: Early Access Players, What Do You Think Of Forza Motorsport So Far?

pip_muzz

As much as I love Xbox this "early 5 day access" is really poor. Forza is probably my favourite gaming series but I'm waiting till launch day still. How long before it's a week early access, or two? Sadly with the sales from this and Starfield as well I doubt Xbox will turn about face, but I shall still vocally call this out as the cynical cash grab it is, charging the "supposed hardcore" fans more for the sake of it