Comments 2,159

Re: Dragon's Dogma 2 Patch Notes Re-Confirmed Ahead Of First Xbox Update

GamingFan4Lyf

@northernmonkey75 Probably take you from an average ~40fps to an average ~42 fps.

I understand that this is Capcom's first foray in open world game with the RE engine, but this doesn't give anyone a great first impression.

And with talks of RE9 going open world, this game doesn't instill confidence it will be any good.

I hope the 30fps cap is at least smooth for those interested in this title.

I am really starting to hate the game industry - especially the "release now, patch later" mentality.

Nintendo are one of the few developers out there who don't rely on "Day 1 Patches". Its games are the only games I have confidence that, when I insert a cartridge into the Switch, I won't be greeted with a lengthy download before I can play.

Re: Talking Point: Has Ray Tracing Been A 'Complete Waste Of Time' For Xbox Series X|S?

GamingFan4Lyf

@NEStalgia Ugh, all that smoothing in TV's is terrible - I turn off all video processing on my TVs.

I do set "film mode" on my TV - but that's for 24fps films and is not soap opera mode.

I will say, if the Default Mode is hot garbage...I do switch it.

I play Final Fantasy XVI at the default Graphics Mode because the 30fps is actually a lock and it's stable where the 60fps isn't.

I did the same for Final Fantasy VII Remake (though I stopped playing a few hours in to focus on FF16 because I try to discipline myself to playing and finish 1 game at a time).

I turned RT on in Resident Evil 4 because the SSR on water bodies was really bad and extremely distracting. The unlocked framerate was covered by VRR.

I left it in Quality Mode on Jedi Survivor.

I left Alan Wake 2 in the Default Mode.

I changed to Performance Mode on Redfall because the game was virtually identical between modes except for 60fps.

I switched to Performance Mode in Elden Ring because those games need to run higher than 30fps and VRR ironed out the framerate drops.

But I understand what you mean about people potentially not getting the best experience either due to marketing decisions or plain ignorance.

Honestly, I wish we didn't have modes. I miss the days of games just being "as is" on consoles. If I want to fiddle with settings, I'd go back to PC gaming. Well...except for 120Hz Mode...I understand having that choice as 120Hz is not standard.

But if a developer wants to make a game target 4K (or 1440p) 60fps on consoles, then make it the best game possible at a locked 60fps on consoles.

If a developer wants to target 4K (or 1440p) at 30fps on consoles, then make it the best game possible at a locked 30fps on consoles.

And no, I don't think developers should get crapped on for making a 30fps with no other options. Usually, you can tell when 30fps was a target as the Performance Mode is extremely compromised and uneven.

Re: Talking Point: Has Ray Tracing Been A 'Complete Waste Of Time' For Xbox Series X|S?

GamingFan4Lyf

@NEStalgia On one hand, I agree with you, but then you see thing things like the Nintendo Switch almost being the highest selling console of all time - beating out consoles with considerably more power.

I would bet a vast majority of people don't even open the Options menu of a console game and simply play on "Default" settings. And I bet those people couldn't even tell you if a game is 30fps or 60fps. 1080p or 4K. Rasterization or real-time RT. They simply don't care.

I know I have gotten to that point. I play on whatever Graphics Mode is the default because I just stopped caring and want to play the game.

The only reason I go into the menu is to ensure spatial audio settings are set (because I care more about that than fussing over Performance or Quality).

That being said, I still stand by what I said about why I want RT to become standard: to take some of the load off artists during development.

Re: Talking Point: Has Ray Tracing Been A 'Complete Waste Of Time' For Xbox Series X|S?

GamingFan4Lyf

People argue if real-time raytracing all together is a waste of time - especially when there is little to no perceptible difference between the rasterized lighting and the ray-traced lighting.

I'd say it's too much for current-gen consoles.

But I don't think RT is a waste of time.

Here's why: it's a huge "time saver" for developers - especially as character models and environmental effects get increasingly more complex. It just starts to get harder to convincingly "fake" proper lighting when more and more objects are on screen or there is more geometric complexity of a scene. That doesn't mean games will come out any faster, it just means that artists can focus on something else more interesting now that lighting elements are handled via RT.

4A games (makers of Metro) has switched over entirely to an RT studio because of the time it saves by not worrying about rasterized lighting "issues".

Rather than having to approximate/handcraft shadows, light placement, bounce lighting, ambient occlusion, etc. having a full RT (or better yet, path-traced) pipeline lets the artists be more like set designers - they place the lights where they want for the desired look without having to worry about ensuring the other aspects of lighting are properly addressed - they just "work".

This opens up more possibilities for artists since the lighting model is completely "trivialized" - perhaps artists can make scenes even more complex. Character models looks more complex. Perhaps even new gameplay mechanics will emerge when light doesn't have to be quite so "hand crafted".

3D at one point looked way worse than 2D Sprite-work. 3D also ran horribly (Star Fox was 15fps, Ocarina of Time was like 25fps, etc). Yet, switching to 3D helped overcome certain obstacles in order to focus on other things that would have become an absolute nightmare using 2D sprites. We are starting to get to that point with lighting, too.

3D rendering has all but become trivial at this point because major players in technology took it seriously enough to actually try to advance it. While it feels like Nvidia is the only one driving the RT train.

So, while the technology certainly doesn't have a huge benefit right now, I do want to continue to see it get used in the future until it becomes a "standard" so developers can focus on improving things elsewhere rather than worrying about whether the GI looks right, or if the shadows are animating at the proper speed and proportions, or if a probe light to simulate "darkness" is too light/dark, etc.

Re: Phil Spencer On Porting Exclusives: 'Every Decision We Make Is To Make Xbox Stronger'

GamingFan4Lyf

This depends on your definition of Xbox, though.

I think a lot of people define Xbox as the physical box with which you use. So, for them, they feel like all the investment they made in the ecosystem becomes moot and should invest elsewhere so that they only have to pay one low price for a console that plays everything.

Microsoft defines Xbox as the gaming wing of Microsoft. So, in that sense, it does make Xbox stronger because it supplies more revenue (and hopefully profit) to the gaming wing of Microsoft.

Re: Major Game Maker Reportedly Questioning Xbox Support Amidst 'Falling Sales'

GamingFan4Lyf

Dear Microsoft,
Make your next console seamlessly run the PC versions of games so that way this whole "no point supporting Xbox" goes away.

The original point of the Xbox was so that people making PC games could easily make a console version. That vision seems to have gone away. I thought the GDK was supposed to streamline Windows and Xbox development, but that doesn't appear to be the case (especially when the GDK on PC is apparently only for games meant to be on Game Pass).

If you still choose a "closed system" then figure out a way to get back the basic principles and make Xbox development so trivial that PC versions can quickly get converted to Xbox versions so that this kind of argument is moot.

Sincerely,
Me

Re: 'Enotria: The Last Song' Dev Cancels Xbox Series X|S Release, For Now

GamingFan4Lyf

@alexcarv_guardiang3 @DJKingaling That would be pretty messed up if they took Microsoft's ID@Xbox money and ran!

I understand the market reach is bigger by focusing on PS5 and PC, but at the same time Microsoft appears to do more for helping indie developers than Nintendo or Sony with the ID@Xbox program.

If this is truly what happened, taking that money and turning around and saying they will "reassess the possibility of an Xbox release post-launch." is the very definition of "biting the hand that feeds."

Re: Xbox Users Are 'Gutted' About The Latest Microsoft Rewards Nerf

GamingFan4Lyf

It's a shame, but, Microsoft is still a business and not a charity.

I am sure everything looked great at first, but it shouldn't come to anyone's surprise that if Microsoft isn't making any money because a lot of people are simply using points to fund Xbox purchases, something was going to change.

Being able to earn points by playing games that can be used to get more games is still pretty darn generous if you ask me - even if you can't get said games as often as you could before.

Re: Dragon's Dogma 2's Microtransactions Are Causing Controversy At Launch

GamingFan4Lyf

@PsBoxSwitchOwner But, again, it had zero hinderance on their gameplay experience.

If the reviewer had reached a point where suddenly a paywall had come up, then, yes, I can see where that would reduce the score - part of the experience is inaccessible/significantly hindered due to having to fork over real money.

None of the actual game experience was hindered during the reviewers playtime. They reviewed the game...not the company's business strategy.

The game they played without shelling out money was a 10/10 in their view (bear in mind, it was also noted that MTX was going to exist when the review was written).

I am not defending MTX by any stretch. I think they are ridiculous, and I simply don't buy them. But if the game is 100% enjoyable without ever needing to fork over extra money, then I don't see dropping a score out of principal or to send a message - people's wallets are a better message to send than a review score.

If MTX were an unknown and then suddenly "poof", MTX showed up, then I can see that as a problem. The reviewer knew it was coming and still gave it a 10/10.

If the MTX suddenly made a whole new area available post-review, then yes, I could where the review would want to amend the review because they didn't get the "whole" experience at time of review.

Neither of those happened.

Without really having knowledge of the game, it looks like the MTX are nothing more than convenience fees for those who want an easier time with the game. The MTX don't seem to be intrusive in any way. Why amend the score?

The reviewer knew they were coming. You know there are there. If the MTX are a problem for you, don't buy them or skip the game all together. That's your choice, just like it was the reviewers choice to still give the game a 10/10 despite knowing MTX were coming.

Re: Remedy's Max Payne Remakes Will Have 'Similar Development Budget' To Alan Wake 2

GamingFan4Lyf

I hope these games will be profitable.

I love Remedy, but I worry about the company as well. It's been taking losses and AW2 has yet to be profitable.

Part of me wonders if partnering with Epic actually ended up being detrimental to the financial success of Alan Wake 2 for two reasons:

Epic Store exclusive (majority of PC players use Steam)
Digital-only release (console players like physical releases)

Hopefully Rockstar doesn't do the same thing and we see Max Payne on all storefronts, plus physical.

Re: Review: Dragon's Dogma 2 (Xbox) - Capcom's Cult Classic Makes A Triumphant Return

GamingFan4Lyf

@InterceptorAlpha So, I found out something interesting:

Series X/PS5/PC use ray-traced global illumination.
Series S does not use ray-traced global illumination.
You can't disable RT on Series X/PS5 (and from what I have seen, the lack of RTGI isn't a huge downgrade)

Every other recent RE game lets you turn RT on/off. Why not Dragon's Dogma 2?! Maybe not taxing the system with RTGI would improve performance?!

It could just be a CPU bottleneck, though.

I would hope that such an option was tested on PS5/Series X and it was found that there wasn't much of a performance difference between RTGI On and Off, so Capcom just decided to leave it on for better image quality.

Re: Review: Dragon's Dogma 2 (Xbox) - Capcom's Cult Classic Makes A Triumphant Return

GamingFan4Lyf

@InterceptorAlpha Seeing as how I have seen people say that this game drops below 30fps on powerful gaming rigs, I wouldn't hold my breath for 60fps mode. But one never knows - perhaps the engineers will discover some major issue with the game that gets patched out and has a transformative effect on the game.

One thing I do find interesting is that on PushSquare mentions the framerate issues in more than just cities on PS5 - but that could be that the reviewer just notices framerate issues more (some people are sensitive to it, others aren't).

I'll be interested in seeing the DF analysis of this.

I can't imagine a huge performance delta, but perhaps this is a title where Xbox has a more favorable outcome with regards to performance.

Overall, this game just sounds too overwhelming for me.

Re: 'The Quarry' Is Available Today With Xbox Game Pass (March 20)

GamingFan4Lyf

I recommend The Quarry to any horror fan out there.

NOTE: decisions and actions you make are less obvious as what would be considered the "correct path" than games in the Dark Pictures Anthology - perhaps that might be more frustrating to some as certain "correct" actions are "hidden" and not finding them could lead to a death much later in the game.

It's a fun romp, though!

Re: Helldivers 2 Dev Urges More 'Compassion' In Response To Negative Xbox Tweet

GamingFan4Lyf

@TheLastHarbinger I'm not debating monopiles in gaming - no one has a monopoly in gaming.

I am merely pointing out how many studios and employees fall under Microsoft's gaming wing compared to Sony since you decided to say that Microsoft is "barely above Sony" which isn't the truth.

Microsoft is a huge publisher now because of Xbox Game Studios, ZeniMax/Bethesda, and ABK. Microsoft has a ton of studios under its belt, now. Nothing more, nothing less.

Microsoft itself has (as of 2023) 221K employees across all divisions. But I don't mention them because Consulting, Azure, Retail, Corporate HR, Microsoft 365, etc. don't have anything to do with gaming.

But if you want to talk revenue, King and Call of Duty money alone is a huge boost to Microsoft Gaming.

Re: Helldivers 2 Dev Urges More 'Compassion' In Response To Negative Xbox Tweet

GamingFan4Lyf

@TheLastHarbinger Microsoft is also the largest game publisher in the world! But, no, not a monopoly...yet (I hope it never gets to be that way)

@HonestHick I like the first-party games Sony has put out. I like the third-party exclusives it manages to get (when it's helping to fund the game and provide technical support, but not paying just to keep the games off Xbox). I don't like Sony.

Re: BG3's Physical Version Runs Into Storage 'Limit' For Xbox, Will Now Ship On Four Discs

GamingFan4Lyf

@rjc-32 Ah, maybe the file size difference could be the culprit. Sucks for a "meager" 500MB.

Then again, that would be a pretty hefty difference in game size to warrant 2 more discs when the PS5 version will probably have just an Install Disc and a Play Disc where the Xbox version will probably have 3 Install Discs and 1 Play Disc. Perhaps it's a combination of both Storage size differences and game data differences.

Re: Xbox Developer inXile Jokingly Teases Its New Game

GamingFan4Lyf

@abe_hikura I had to look that one up. Wow, that is some really well-done animation for a slice of bread! Kudos to RGG Studio for that.

I rewatched the trailer after looking at that bread, and it doesn't surprise me that something as simple as bread looks that good. Everything looks extremely polished. I am sure the footage is from a high-spec PC, but it's a beautiful game.

I think it's UE5 since it was announced a while back that InXile was working with the engine.

Re: Remedy Purchases Full Rights To 'Control' Franchise From 505 Games

GamingFan4Lyf

@eire-shabba Control was influenced by the SCP Foundation, so if you like that kind of stuff, then Control would be right up your alley.

I am glad Remedy has full...uhm...control over this IP. It would be nice if Remedy could also get full rights to Max Payne but I don't see Rockstar giving that up.

I wonder if Quantum Break will be next - very underrated title, if you ask me and I think a multi-platform release could help get a wider audience.

Re: Rockstar Asks Employees To Return To Office Full-Time In Preparation For GTA 6

GamingFan4Lyf

Must be a generational thing to kick up a fuss about going back to the office.

I have been lucky enough to have been working from home for a while now, but I wouldn't moan and groan if I was expected to work in an office again - it does have its benefits.

This is coming from a person who has had to commute an hour to an office for the better part of 12 years.

Would I prefer to be at home working? Absolutely - it's prevented our family from having to find after school care for my daughter.

Would I cry "foul" because I would have to go to an office every day? No, it's just the nature of work.

I work in software development and collaboration happens much more often when everyone is in the same office together to either ask for help or bounce ideas off each other.

Sure, there are messengers and online meetings, but it's not the same. I have people on my team I don't even really "know" at all because I only ever hear their voices during daily standup or the occasional call.

Re: Poll: Will You Be Buying The Star Wars: Battlefront 'Classic Collection'?

GamingFan4Lyf

@luke88 The only time I ever play multiplayer is if my daughter wants me to play Mario Kart 8 with her.

But yes, it applies to all multiplayer games. I don't buy fighting games. I don't buy sports games. I don't buy games that revolve around multiplayer.

When I was in college, I enjoyed playing Quake and Counter Strike (back when it was still a Half-Life Mod) with people in the dorms. When I was in the Navy I played some Halo multiplayer with my shipmates when on deployment. I played a lot of Warhammer Online when it was still a thing and WoW.

After becoming a family man, though, I simply lost interest mostly due to time restrictions. I tried here and there, but I got no joy out of it and ended up hating it all together.

I just don't have the time to "git gud" against people who sit on the game all day. It's not fun for me anymore.

With the hour (if I am lucky) time I get to play games per day, I'd rather get lost in a single-player experience than deal with online toxicity.

If I do play any multiplayer (and that's a HUGE if), it would be co-op and not competitive.

Re: Xbox And Microsoft Reveal Full GDC 2024 Schedule

GamingFan4Lyf

@HonestHick I just hate that 40fps modes are tied to 120Hz because my TV can handle 40fps via VRR.

I hear you on older games. When I am taking a break from Final Fantasy 16 (e.g. missus is using the TV), I am playing PS2/Gamecube era and older games on my laptop. I am really going deep into gaming history. LOL!