Comments 271

Re: Review: Forza Horizon 5: Hot Wheels – Back For An Enjoyable Second Lap

RedShirtRod

Great review. I agree with your opinion that locking the existing car collection is odd. Wouldn't mind if they had done that at the start of the base game to give a little direction but many of those still playing have sunk 100s of hours into this game. Locking cars we've earned is just strange.

I also agree that the zones are pretty but unused. Reminds me a lot of Anthem. Great scenery but shallow in content. The lack of substantial accolades kind of proves it. I felt that adding a variety of accolades in the base game gave goals to keep players entertained but the Academy goals can be completed fairly quickly and with little exploration.

It's a good dlc but if you've been playing the franchise for the past decade it does seem to be lacking in creativity.

Re: Pick One: Which Of These Simulation Games Is Your Favourite On Xbox Game Pass?

RedShirtRod

@sjbsixpack handling a plane is always harder on a simulator than in real life. You can feel when the plane is wanting to turn, hits of turbulence, and just normal action with the yoke in real life, not so much on a game. My first day we did a flight on a Glein Simulator and my instructor crashed landed. If you can keep a steady flight with Flight Sim then my opinion is you'll have a leg up on real life flying.

Disclaimer: my private is in a piper warrior and I don't dare assume I know everything about other single engine props.

Re: Xbox Exec Claims Crunch At Bethesda Is A Thing Of The Past

RedShirtRod

I have to think there is some truth to this from the consistent delays we are seeing from games. The overworking has gone down but marketing and scheduling hasn't caught up yet. Games are just going to take more time to develop than they use to and I think you'll start seeing less hard dates so early before release.

Re: Halo: The Master Chief Collection Might Be Adding Microtransactions

RedShirtRod

@Bleachedsmiles Agreed. I can't understand why it isn't all hands on deck for Infinite. Stop trying to milk the old games and ensure that people will give a care for the new ones. Saw that rumor that the first story DLC for Infinite will take 3 years to come out. This team needs to get their heads out of their rears soon or the only Halo games anyone will care about will be the on the MCC.

Re: Even Halo's Co-Creator Isn't Sure Where The Show's 'Inspiration' Is Coming From...

RedShirtRod

The show was dead on arrival when creators didn't play the games and the show was deemed non-canon. What is sad is that Halo could really use a show to expand its universe. We don't get enough dialog in the video games from chief to make a deep plot and books/comics don't cut it. They could have created whatever they wanted but they decided to butcher what little lore there actually is.

Re: Reaction: Bethesda Delays Make June's Showcase Even More Important For Xbox

RedShirtRod

@awp69 Losing out on one game isn't enough to break Gamepass but it needs to be a wake up call for Microsoft. Last year their schedule was

July - Flight Simulator
August - Psychonauts
October - Age of Empires 4
November - Forza Horizon 5
December - Halo Infinite

This year has been nothing. Their pacing is off. Release a game a quarter. If you've got two then hold one back and either let developers work a little more on it or use it in case of a delay. Subscriptions are different than normal releases and Microsoft needs to figure it out.

Re: Certain Changes Are Proving Unpopular In Halo Infinite Season 2

RedShirtRod

I'm in the negative fan boat. Already mentioned my dislike of last man standing so I won't go into again but I also agree the challenges stink as well. You get to decide on trying to win or trying to get that fifth backsmack. Want to play fiesta? Too bad, you'll only get rewards for stronghold matches (good luck finding one). It's random and it takes away progressive nature of the battle pass system.

We want to play your game 343. Stop trying to make it more difficult than that.

Re: Halo Infinite Season 2: Last Spartan Standing Guide

RedShirtRod

I've played probably two dozen matches of last spartan standing and I'm not a fan. It favors those that are really good which isn't too big of a problem except there already are modes designed for those players in mind. I honestly don't understand the difference between this and free for all except you're locked into specific weapons. Those that are good with the starting weapons are rewarded while those that aren't are getting stuck in leveling purgatory.

When the weekly challenges are this, tactical, and ranked matches it doesn't really inspire casual players to jump back in. Games like CoD and Fortnite stay relevant because it keeps the casuals entertained. No one likes getting brutally destroyed in games without any measure of improvement or reward.

It also doesn't help that 343i picked developing this over firefight. I would rather they brought back a fan favorite over another version of me getting creamed by one hardcore player five times in a row.

TLDR: If you're relatively good at Halo this version is fine, to all others it's a baffling decision.

Re: Damning Report Takes Aim At Xbox's State Of Decay 3 Studio

RedShirtRod

@lolwhatno Sony had their fair share of gripes with Naughty Dog during TLOU2 with their 70% attrition rate and overworking employees. This trend of people speaking out isn't based against one publisher or company, but the industry at large.

My argument though is how these are being presented. Companies that are directly accused of enabling sexual assault need to be universally condemned. Complaints that of long work hours or not feeling like your voice was heard needs a little more proof and differing viewpoints before consumers can make an informed decision.

Re: Damning Report Takes Aim At Xbox's State Of Decay 3 Studio

RedShirtRod

Yeah, read the Kotaku article before making any judgment. I just finished it and it contradicts itself a couple times. Not trying to discount people's concerns but the article seems to say Microsoft was too hands off while also saying Microsoft removed Schlosser when issues came to light.

It's hard to support anonymous people's concerns when they aren't consistent on their examples.

Re: Xbox Reportedly Paid '$5-10 Million' For Guardians Of The Galaxy On Game Pass

RedShirtRod

@Kopite @Stocksy It's impossible to know for certain. Monthly service fees are always more popular than yearly ones and while there are always going to be people who go looking for deals, the $10 price is the low end, not the high end. Ultimate is $15 a month, which is why I assumed it offset those getting discount deals.

Once again, everything we have to go off is assumptions but I highly doubt the majority of players are going through the hassle of getting discounts. Forums like these are going to have a larger number of them because that's the kind of people we are. If the larger public knew about the deals (like the EA pass awhile back) Microsoft would just stop offering them.

Re: Xbox Announces New Cloud Gaming Initiative

RedShirtRod

Currently deployed where internet isn't great but xcloud has still been fairly good. Been rocking through ME2 again on my phone and it's pretty awesome. Hardcore gamers might not like it but then again this isn't for them. Options are rarely a bad thing. If more companies support xcloud then good on them.

Re: Activision Blizzard Warns Of Financial Consequences If Microsoft Deal Falls Through

RedShirtRod

@UltimateOtaku91 I think that's doubtful. Look at the merger between Sprint and T-mobile. Made US phone service effectively a three carrier market between them, Verizon, and AT&T. Same with Disney and Fox studios. Anti-trust laws in the US have changed drastically over the past century, heavily favoring mergers and buyouts when both of them are American companies. Microsoft has also changed their lobbying since their legal issues in the early 2000's. If they're putting games on playstation it's not to sway regulators, that's for sure.

Re: Gran Turismo 7 Drama Leads To 'Always-Online' Xbox And PlayStation Debate

RedShirtRod

I don't think it would have been as big of a deal if the price wasn't as high and the patch that just came out. Most reasonable people understand games are different today and patches have a tendency to have issues. Games like GT7 have a singleplayer that ties into multiplayer so it makes sense you can't have people jump in and out of connection.

It's the other two issues that broke this camel's back. Breaking a game for 24 hours is bad but doing it to push microtransactions is unacceptable. Also don't charge $70 for game and break it within the first month. Just look at how Outriders was different. Only $15 on Gamepass and they worked their bums off to fix online issues from the get go. They didn't charge $70, wait for good reviews, and then start tinkering.

Re: Xbox Series X|S Outsells PS5 Across Europe In February

RedShirtRod

@Tharsman Agreed. Even though there is a stock shortage they are still impressive numbers if only from Microsoft resource allocation. The company sells a lot more than gaming hardware and could probably use those chips in other departments. The fact that they are still out producing Sony in both the US and parts of Europe is a good sign of how they view the Xbox brand.

Re: E3 Will Supposedly Go Ahead In 2022, Despite Cancellation Claims

RedShirtRod

I still love E3. It has been a huge anchor for fan expectations and I personally haven't enjoyed the move away from it. People never use to ask about what is in the pipeline because you knew they would tell you during E3. Now people have unfounded expectations for State of Plays and Directs that we get questions all the time about what publishers are doing.

Super excited it is back this year and I hope most of the big publishers will make an appearance.

Re: Talking Point: Is It Time For Another Xbox Event Soon?

RedShirtRod

Seeing how Microsoft is in the process of owning what feels like half the major players of E3 whatever event they do will be expected to be similar in scale. Best they do their own event at the beginning of summer and use the other events to reveal more details on already announced games.

Re: Xbox Boss Responds To Sceptics, Uses Price Of Game Pass As Example

RedShirtRod

If Microsoft was desperate enough to get more revenue they wouldn't have dropped over $76 billion buying Activision and Zenimax. Even by doubling the monthly subscription, it would take decades to make that back, and that's if everyone stayed. Anybody who thinks that's Microsoft's goal clearly doesn't understand business strategy.

If you want to know what their plan is look at the history of Internet Explorer and Netscape. Microsoft was ruthless in their takedown of Netscape and they did it by attacking at them sideways. That's the reason you don't pay for Chrome or Firefox. Companies like Microsoft don't need to raise prices to be competitive and successful.

Re: Sony Boss Tells PlayStation Owners To 'Expect More Acquisitions'

RedShirtRod

@UltimateOtaku91 @RevGaming probably not Warner Bros. At&t is too close in size of Sony for them not to push for a high selling point. Even Microsoft and Tencent probably would struggle getting a reasonable deal.

Sony has roughly $30B on hand but spending anywhere near that would be an awful idea. They have to still support their film and electronic divisions and any issues with that could be devastating without reserve funds.

If Sony is going for developers it will be single studios like Insomniac and Bungie.

Re: Sony Acquiring Bungie For $3.6 Billion, Studio Will Remain Multiplatform

RedShirtRod

@mousieone @Savage_Joe As much as we like to think Bungie and MS have a bond their partnership ended over a decade ago. I'd be interested to know how many that are working there now are from the time MS was their publisher.

The only bond they truly had was Halo. MS shouldn't feel any negative feelings about it.

Just super strange that the company that fought free of Activision and MS jumps in with Sony. Just shows how much the company has changed.

Re: Some Activision Games Will Still Release On PlayStation, Claims Report

RedShirtRod

It makes sense. I mentioned this elsewhere but a purchase like this isn't aimed at Sony. Not saying it won't affect them but there are better ways for MS to spend $70B if they wanted to "crush" PS.

MS has been honest that they see Tencent and Apple as their main competitors, not Sony. Activision was sinking and this kept Microsoft in the game. My guess is you'll see stronger build up of King compared to Blizzard or Activision main. And if selling games (probably at a premium) on PS helps MS, they'll do it.

Re: Pick One: Which Is Your Favourite Assassin's Creed Xbox Game?

RedShirtRod

@Odium I hated the story but loved the naval combat. Felt the characters were forgettable and the plot pretty basic. I remember watching the last cutscene where he sees all those he lost and I couldn't tell who half of them were.

The combat was good in spite of being an AC game. Being able to assassinate people on a ship that you've been attacking for the last 3 minutes is pretty ridiculous.