Medic_alert

Medic_alert

I feel like I've been here before

Comments 218

Re: Five Things An Xbox Handheld Needs To Include When It Releases

Medic_alert

The handheld PC market has made a lot of noise but has made very little real impact on the market. I don't see the Xbox branded handheld making any in-roads in that.

As for a fully fledged Xbox in your hands - the console needs to be a simple pick up and play device, with a good screen and decent battery life. It needs to be comfortable for long play sessions too and the sticks need to be pretty much drift proof and that all has to come in at a reasonable price.

And it still won't sell well.

Re: Talking Point: If The Next-Gen Xbox Is More 'PC-Like', Will You Still Buy It?

Medic_alert

All depends on the implementation.

There are some possibilities that would be amazing, the library would be huge and only Nintendo games would be (legally) off the console.

However, I can't see how this doesn't lead to a system that requires way more tinkering than a console and the idea of running anything windows is enough to put me off completely - The Xbox has enough weird unstable moments as it is.

It feels like an attempt to be everything to all people but I'm not convinced that's possible.

It also sounds expensive...

Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (March 8-9)

Medic_alert

Having sunk lots of time into Avowed and enjoyed it a lot I'm now taking a break from normal games to play some PSVR 2.

Using it as a way to be a bit less sedentary. Bringing out the old favourite - Pistol whip and then Synth Riders and Beat Sabre, plus a decent amount of Drums Rock thrown in.

I also played thr opening of Metro awakening but finding myself having trouble adjusting to the control scheme.

Re: Hundreds Of Delisted Xbox 360 Games Now Have The Potential To Return On PC

Medic_alert

If big corporations can't get together to do something worthwhile with this stuff then I'm all for people trying to find other solutions.

People will scream piracy but this hobby has had a long history of forced obsolescence making legitimate purchases useless in some cases and in others attempting to get people to buy things over and over with re-releases and remasters.

I have no problem at all with people finding ways to play old games.

Re: Xbox Series X|S Sales Down Almost 50% As Fans Question Stock Levels In Certain Regions

Medic_alert

@dskatter I'm sure there will be lots of people that feel the same but MS clearly don't care about that.

I mean they may do an add on drive for b/c purposes but given that they have dropped a fair few games now with no physical copies and outside of COD none of the games they have dropped on other consoles have had a physical copy then I think this is inevitable at this point.

Re: Poll: What Do You Think Of 'Balatro' On Xbox Game Pass So Far?

Medic_alert

@Titntin it's the subversion of the rules of poker and the standard deck of cards that makes the game later on.

Modifying your deck of cards and jokers to blow apart what is possible with a straight poker deck is the fun of the game. Having to lay down your own sets of rules in the first place would not be as affective because there is no expectation in how those rules play out.

Re: Xbox Co-Creator Calls VR 'Disappointing' As Sony Slashes Price Of PSVR2

Medic_alert

For me the tech is brilliant and utterly transformative in the appropriate game.

I wish PSVR2 had Half Life on it but otherwise the £300 i spent on it has been a joy.

However, as a business decision, I totally agree that Xbox was right not to head down that route because it hasn't quite taken off and to be fair in that period Xbox weren't getting normal console games out let alone a bunch of VR ones as well.

I highly recommend playing VR if you haven't though. I dare you to play pistol whip and not be entertained!

Re: Xbox & PlayStation Owners Are Obsessed With Live Service Games Right Now

Medic_alert

I'd love a bit more granularity to this data.

I do wonder if I'm part of the 70% having played single player modes in live service games - efootball and Cod.

And what is the definition of live service. Push Square has posited a very wide definition of live service - one i don't subscribe to but it highlights that you need the definition to be clear on what this really means.

Re: Xbox RPG Avowed Seemingly Sold Well Despite Being In Game Pass

Medic_alert

I have gone from thinking the game is good to feeling like it is brilliant and I am playing a tonne of it. 34 hours in now.

I'd be curious as to how much this cost to make though. In many ways it doesn't feel AAA and I suspect adding some of that AAA 'polish' would have been expensive and added very little.

Anyway, I think it is wonderful and I hope we get more in the future.

Re: January Hardware Sales The Worst Since 2020 In The US As Xbox Consoles Decline By 50%

Medic_alert

@omno I tend to agree with most of this view.

I think Xbox hardware will be there as long as it is profitable and as soon as it isn't then MS game studios takes over and Xbox are an all digital services and software arm of Microsoft.

I can see them going the surface route - but that means unsubsidised (read - expensive) hardware, the only caveat to that is that Phil Spencer did say they want to keep hardware affordable. I'm not sure he is driving this train anymore though.

Re: January Hardware Sales The Worst Since 2020 In The US As Xbox Consoles Decline By 50%

Medic_alert

@nomither6 fair point to mention going PC isn't all about power.

I don't buy the idea that you can corden off one piece of hardware and say it doesn't compete with any others. Everyone has limited time and money and unless you can afford to buy every game on every platform then they very much compete with each other for both your time and money.

Anyway, I stand by my initial statement that I don't believe this to be anything to do with PC sales - unless of course you have data to show otherwise?

Re: January Hardware Sales The Worst Since 2020 In The US As Xbox Consoles Decline By 50%

Medic_alert

@nomither6 still doesn't change the fact that rarely has power been the main draw of a console.

And I have no idea why you are throwing the competitor/not competitor argument at me. It isn't one I'm making. When you are talking about selling over 100m machines all media is in competition for your time and money whether directly or indirectly. How you want to classify those things is of no interest to me.

And handhelds don't always outsell the home hardware. The Vita being the easy response but the 3ds didn't outsell the Xbox 360, PS3 or PS4.

Re: January Hardware Sales The Worst Since 2020 In The US As Xbox Consoles Decline By 50%

Medic_alert

@Millionski this is my feeling too. Coming up to 4.5 years and this gen feels like we are just getting into it.

This is also part of the reason I think you're seeing the numbers above. The cross-gen period has just about faded out now but for many the PS4 and X1 will still play fortnite etc and the current machines have seen no price drop as would normally be the case and have actually gone up in price on the background of some of the hardest economic times since the 80s.

Neither Sony or MS have played a good enough hand to justify massive console sales at this point.

Re: Talking Point: Are You Happy With The Current Xbox UI As It Stands In 2025?

Medic_alert

It's fine my biggest issue with the OS is not the UI but the inconsistency in the way it runs.

It doesn't seem to have consistent rules to when a button press takes you back one screen or back to the home screen.

It also still does weird things like getting stuck on 'finishing up' games. It just has random little errors and as such feels very 'windows' to use.

Also why doesn't scrolling with the triggers work in the store?

It just feels a bit inconsistent all round to me.

Re: Xbox's New Strategy Is 'Right' For The Business And Needs To Be Embraced, Says Former Exec

Medic_alert

@armondo36 then I will move away from all of it.

But I have heard this assumption before and it only works if consumers buy into it - which i won't.

I don't agree that the others will follow. Both Nintendo and Sony are much much smaller than MS and their business model relies on being a platform holder - they don't have a trillion dollar business backing them to drop that revenue.

They could, I suppose end up just being an app on other devices but again that isn't something I'd support.