Comments 455

Re: Xbox Boss Praises Community For 'Really Great' Support On PC

Menchi

@Medic_Alert My favourites were all the pictures captioned "oh nice homage, they even used the original geometry/textures!"

Push Square users hate me because they refuse to acknowledge that Sony money led to an inferior experience of a 3rd party game. The users praised Sony for locking it to PS4. The same users were also up in arms over Microsoft getting Yakuza 7 timed next gen exclusivity.

@BlueOcean I wish they would've just went with a next gen launch title. So many problems with that game.

Re: Xbox Boss Praises Community For 'Really Great' Support On PC

Menchi

This comment is made from how it benefits me, and not how I view the "Xbox brand" overall and what the practices are doing or perceived to be doing to it.

Halo 5 was the last Xbox One game I played because everything after that was on PC at the same time, thankfully. I love that Microsoft have been bringing their games to PC day and date (sometimes even 1st to PC, with Gears Tactics, etc) as I enjoy many of their games and I never have to worry about terrible console level performance and/or visuals.

I wish every console maker would do "their console + PC" as I hate playing a good game and it has low resolution or terrible frame rate or even the mess that was FF7R because of console limitations running out of texture memory.

Re: Halo Infinite Dev Addresses Criticism Of The Game's Graphics

Menchi

Microsoft have spent the best part of a year with "world's most powerful console, 4k this, 4k that, 12 TERAFLOPS!!!!" as their key selling point. And they headline their 1st party next gen showcase, with their flagship IP, looking significantly worse than some of Sony's last gen games on a console around 1/9th of the power, or the PC remasters of earlier games in the series (Halo MCC).

If I showed someone a close up of someone from TLOU2 or Ghosts Of Tsushima or some other recent Sony 1st party game and showed someone the close up of the brute from the end of the Halo Infinite trailer, which do you think they'd say is next gen.

Edit: Fire Aaron Greenberg.

Re: Poll: Has July's Xbox Showcase Changed Your Mind On Xbox Series X?

Menchi

@mousieone I actually have almost every mainstream console there is from the 3rd gen up. Because there were reasons to own them. Exclusive games. Since I have a better PC than Xbox Series X (and will have an even better one later this year when I rebuild), and can buy all the games on there, I have no need to waste the money.

But if what we saw yesterday is the best they can do with their flagship franchise, this isn't worth my time or money.

Re: Poll: Has July's Xbox Showcase Changed Your Mind On Xbox Series X?

Menchi

I was planning on getting an Xbox just for Youtube purposes because the viewers would like the small bit of comparative coverage.

But at this point after today I can't justify it. I was going to be playing everything on PC myself as it was, but the showcase really made it apparent I don't need the Xbox One X+1. Even the 4k trailer versions just weren't good enough.

It's not the hardware. At this point it's the talentless developers. I hate to make the comparison, but Sony has PS4 games looking better than next gen Xbox.

I wish this were not the case.

Re: Seagate's Xbox Series X Storage Expansion Card Web Page Goes Live

Menchi

@Medic_Alert The drives with the speeds required for the PS5 are top of the line and therefore already very expensive. To change that into a proprietary media would make them cost even more.

As an example, the 1st drive that is PS5 compatible (it's actually faster than the PS5, which makea it compatible) is supposed to be launching next month and will be around the €500 mark for 2TB.

Re: Microsoft Flight Simulator Lands On PC Next Month

Menchi

@AJDarkstar And this time they're doing it correctly. I look forward to continuing to play Microsoft's multiplatform games on PC day and date going forward. It's you that hangs onto "what Xbox is" while everyone else moves on with what it has actually become.

Re: Resi Evil Survey Asks If Players Would Buy A Digital Only Xbox Series X

Menchi

I wouldn't buy one despite my Xbox One being almost entirely digital. I have a few early physical games but when the deep sales hit I converted almost every game I keep installed and plan to play from all 3 gens to digital. All my Microsoft games are bought on PC for the last 5 years, as are all my 3rd party multiplats, Despite being pro physical media, my Xbox has become basically all digital outside of 2-3 BC games and a 4k bluray player. But the option for physical media is the important thing.

Re: Rumour: Lockhart Dev Kit Easy To Use, Won't Hold Back Xbox Series X

Menchi

As I've tried to educate people on "all TFLOPS are not created equal". The difference in CPU/GPU architecture will yield much better performance and improvements than incomparable numbers suggest.

Xbox Series S will outperform the Xbox One X versions of games easily. Despite less TFLOPS and slightly less RAM. GPU RAM becomes more efficient for older things as new architecture improves. A quick example:

When I first played Max Payne 3 on my GTX690 at 1080p, it used around 3.9gb of my VRAM to max everything for 60fps. Then using a GTX1080 at 1440p (approximately 77% more pixels than 1080p) and doubling the framerate to 120fps, maxed out would require about 2.4gb VRAM.

So despite the RAM and perceived TFLOP disparity of the X1X and XSS, the XSS will be significantly better in every way. Or at least it is capable of being better in every way, as long as Microsoft and whatever dev in question doesn't do it incorrectly.

That and the Jaguar and GCN have always been absolute garbage.