Comments 455

Re: Codemasters Dev: The Xbox Series S Is An Amazing Piece Of Kit

Menchi

@BlueOcean The big problem in X1X/XSS BC in some cases would look like this example. It may not be every game, but it's just something to consider.

Xbox One version: 720p. 900p, 1080p
Xbox One X version: Native 4k with high quality textures (be it 4k textures or somewhere still higher than original resolution)
Xbox Series S version: 1440p, original 720/900/1080 textures.

X1X enhancements aren't just "higher rendering resolution", there was more to the package than that. Of course it's on a game by game basis and some X1X games were just "native 4k, same quality settings" but it's why I feel a blanket statement doesn't do anything for the argument, be it for or against.

Re: Xbox Series S Won't Hold Back Next-Gen 'In The Slightest', Says Dev

Menchi

I'm more curious about the other dev posts making the rounds. That XSS won't be able to play the X1X enhanced versions of Xbox One games. Advanced GPU aside, the XSS has both less ram and slower memory bandwidth than Xbox One X.

Now typically better GPUs use less VRAM when doing the same (or better) on older games but that's because they usually have the same or better memory bus and bandwidth.

Re: Video: This Is How Quickly The Xbox Series S Can Load Games

Menchi

@Z3u5000 Oh I assumed it had a next gen optimised version, which is why it was disappointing. Afterall, why show a last gen game, why not show all this next gen superpower.

Since my 550mbps SATA3 SSD loads faster than that (on an overall more powerful CPU/GPU though, so no bottleneck from those).

Can't wait for the new Sabrent Rocket 4 (better than the new EVO overall) with RTX I/O.

Re: Rumour: Could The Xbox Series X 1TB Expansion Card Be Upwards Of $200?!

Menchi

@blinx01 New tech is questionable in this case. It's the proprierary side of it that is driving up the price, 2400mbps PCIE 4.0 drives are not that new.

@BANJO I have about 384gb free on my Xbox One X. But I could easily increase it to about 700gb or more. I keep pretty much anything I COULD be interested installed (it's only BC games and Halo 5). And I only keep so much installed because I'm trying to justify not having only Halo 5 installed.

Re: Rumour: Could The Xbox Series X 1TB Expansion Card Be Upwards Of $200?!

Menchi

As @PcTV says, the normal drive price is a little under this, then factor in Xbox branding (remember the terrible 360/One external pocket hdds? Terrible 5400rpm 2.5" drive) and more importantly, proprietary tech, I'd say this is accurate.

Edit: As an extra aside, even though the PS5 uses standardised M.2 NVME drives, the spec on them is very high end so you're talking even more expensive than these Xbox drives despite no playstation branding or proprietary tech. PC drives now exceed the PS5 and you're talking around €500 for 2tb

Re: Poll: Which Design Do You Prefer, Xbox Series S Or X?

Menchi

@Z3u5000 This isn't a pro in playstation's favour, but VRS sucks. I guess it's nice to have the option when you're limited on power (like all 3 consoles) but it looks worse in every case in the few games so far that have it. I call it "dynamic shadow quality" basically since VRS looks worse in every analysed case.

Re: Poll: Which Next-Gen Xbox Are You Currently Planning To Buy?

Menchi

@KelticDevil Because Xbox games come to PC as well. And we play on Xbox Live. The article is specifically asking users if they are getting it. I have a better PC than XSX and will have a VASTLY superior one in 2 weeks. Xbox consoles offer nothing TO ME, so buying one would be a waste of money FOR ME.

Sorry if your brand loyalty hurts your reading comprehension that badly.

I can play every future Xbox game (and all 3rd party games and even some Sony games) better than any of the 3 consoles can. Next gen Xbox consoles are absolutely a waste of money......FOR ME, as was asked by the article.

Re: Poll: Which Next-Gen Xbox Are You Currently Planning To Buy?

Menchi

Halo July presentation turned me off buying either Xbox. My PC is already more powerful than the XSX and with my upcoming upgrade, there is no comparison whatsoever.

I was always on the fence about buying the console because I don't need it, but for other reasons. At this point, it's just a waste of money in my eyes. As for the XSS, it doesn't even exist to me.