Comments 218

Re: Elden Ring Will Be Easier Than Other Souls Games, But Has No Difficulty Options

Dezzy

@NEStalgia

Yeah but Fromsoft games sell a hell of a lot more than Metroid and Castlevania do, which was the point I was making earlier. So they've done a lot better with difficulty being the main selling point, and have less need to change that.

I don't agree that the difficulty is that simple, although it does change massively between their different games, so it's a bit hard to generalize about all of them. Dark Souls 1 though, is probably the clearest example difficulty infusing the level design. You have metal boulders rolling down stairs to crush you, swinging guillotines to knock you off thin walkways, greatbow archers shooting arrows that knock you off the edge of a cathedral, gaps that you have to jump across the reach new area. The list is almost endless. If they were going to make an easy mode for that game, it would be so much more complicated than just a simple damage multiplier.

My worry is that if they did add an easy mode, it would influence their future game design, so they'd deliberately stop including those kinds of environmental difficulties, and everything would just become HP counts and damage amounts, which would be a big loss for the series.

Re: Elden Ring Will Be Easier Than Other Souls Games, But Has No Difficulty Options

Dezzy

@NEStalgia

Yeah it's definitely not 10 million hardcore fans. It's more like 6 million hardcore fans (the number of copies they usually sell in the first year or so), and then another 4 million normies.

My objections to adding easier difficulty though are
1) I don't know if it would make any more people play it, for the reasons I've mentioned.
2) It's not that easy to do with these games because difficulty is so interwoven with the game design. Something like a simple damage multiplier really wouldn't suit these games very well (which is what most easy modes are)
3) I worry that the series would lose it's dedicated hard-core fanbase if it became more mainstream. We would lose something that's quite unique in the games industry. Something like Vaati Vidya having 2 million subscribers is way more impressive than you see for something like Zelda, for example. Zelda which has sold more than Fromsoft in recent history, yet has a tiny fraction of the devoted audience. I think there's a reason for that. The love of shared difficulty is part of it.

Re: Elden Ring Will Be Easier Than Other Souls Games, But Has No Difficulty Options

Dezzy

@Arcnail

Yes but I'm suggesting the comparative sales numbers is a good way to test that, and it doesn't support that conclusion.
I think what's actually happened is that they have a much bigger audience than they otherwise would specifically BECAUSE they did such a good job of having this unique selling point of being brutally hard (but fair), and so they attracted a lot of people who weren't necessarily ARPG fans at all, but just loved a challenge (e.g maybe Megaman fans).
Now it may be true that they could add an easy mode at this point without actually losing any of those fans they already have, but it's definitely possible that once they start trying to go more mainstream, it will start affecting how they design the whole game, and will bleed into so many other aspects of it, that they actually would alienate those original fans, and end up selling less because of it. I can easily imagine that happening, because the difficulty in Dark Souls is so interwoven with how the games are set up.

Re: Elden Ring Will Be Easier Than Other Souls Games, But Has No Difficulty Options

Dezzy

@NEStalgia

The sales figures for each of their games are very very similar. Usually around 10 million over the course of 3 years. That suggests to me that it is mostly a consistent fanbase who've played all of them.
Also see how big some of the Soulsborne youtube channels are. Vaati has nearly 2 million subscribers, for a channel JUST about Souls stuff. I think that suggests it is mostly just a large community of people who buy all their games.

Re: Xbox Boss Praises God Of War Director’s Leadership Following Sequel Delay

Dezzy

This happens to literally everyone on the internet who does or says anything controversial. It's annoying, sure, but it's hardly a news story at this point in time.
I got a random death threat just this week from some weirdo. I just muted them and that was that. That's just what the internet is. It's no use complaining about it unless you have an actual solution.