
BioWare's next big entry in the Dragon Age series is out this week and the critic reviews are now rolling in...
In case you missed it, we've already reviewed Dragon Age: The Veilguard here on Pure Xbox - awarding it an "excellent" nine out of ten stars. Here's a bit about what our reviewer PJ O'Reilly thought about it:
"This is a top-class action-RPG that lives up to the Dragon-Age name whilst laying to rest the ghosts of Mass Effect: Andromeda and Anthem. With a roster of amazing companions to recruit, a mind-bending world full of exquisite regions to explore, and combat that raises the bar in every possible way for the franchise, this is the good stuff, thank you very much."
So, what did other critics have to say? The aggregate score for Veilguard is currently in the 80s on Metacritic and Open Critic. Here's a roundup so far:
CGM Magazine (10/10):
"Dragon Age: The Veilguard is the Game of the Year contender to beat. With a gorgeous, detailed art style, a combat system that works wonders, a story that can really pull your morals in all directions and companions that kick ass"
Games Radar (4.5/5)
"Despite some small caveats, playing through a new Dragon Age game after 10 long years has been both personally cathartic and surreal, and likely would have been even if I'd not genuinely largely enjoyed myself throughout. To absolutely butcher the Grey Warden motto in service to my point, if this was all a war for our collective time and money, Dragon Age: The Veilguard feels like a victory."
PC Gamer (79/100)
"The Veilguard nails action combat and exploration and visual grandeur but in a series about defining a hero with morally ambiguous choices, the choices here are too easy to make. In time, The Veilguard will have its own hotly debated legacy within the series, but thank goodness it will at least have one."
Game Reactor UK (8/10)
"Bioware is back, and while they're not reinventing the wheel here, they've made exactly the game we wanted them to make. An exclusively single-player RPG that is narratively anchored, far more linear, with all the content tailored and organised by skilled designers and without all the "bloat"... What you have here is lean and mean, and it puts Bioware on an exciting trajectory where it's finally possible to see light at the end of the very dark tunnel they've been in for a long, long while. It's not a perfect RPG, but it's... pretty damn good, to say the least."
RPG Site (7/10)
"The seams and rough edges feel like the result of the development team at least in part rearranging and adapting existing work and ideas to suit the game's vision, but lacking the resources or ability to make them shine as they should. But though it's ultimately held back its shortcomings, the other highs of Dragon Age: The Veilguard - its characters, its storytelling, and its sense of personality - make the game easy to like despite the flaws. The issues may be harder to look past for some, but others will find joy in the things it does do well."
Push Square (8/10)
"Dragon Age: The Veilguard isn't quite BioWare back to its absolute best, but it is the most cohesive and emotionally engaging RPG that the studio has delivered since Mass Effect 3. Its shift to crunchy action combat is an improvement over Inquisition's middle-of-the-road approach, and although the game feels a little light on meaningful player choice, the storytelling pulls no punches when it actually matters."
Will you be giving this game a go on Xbox? Let us know in the comments.
Comments 27
Shills, bought and paid for.
More reviews than just these of course, ranging from the very low end of “not recommended” all the way up to “BioWare’s best ever!”
I’m not much for action combat, but I’ll try it out on game pass in a year when it hits ea play.
@Ancelyn13 oh come on. Just because some people like it doesn’t mean they were bought off. Plenty of people like it and plenty seem to think it’s mediocre too. There is a variety of opinion. That’s probably how it should be, although it’s rare.
These scores don't align with what I think of the game, therefore, they must be paid!
Geez, the gaming community is more toxic than ever nowadays.
I, for one, am glad that the game is reviewing good.
I'll still wait for a sale or EA Play, but I'm glad.
The whole withholding review codes thing is a definite yikes, so not sure how positive the reception actually is.
Not to mention the actually negative reviews from trusted reviewers such as SkillUp.
@freddones the varying grades would be because a review is one person's opinion, and people have varying opinions.
@freddones hard disagree on trusting Steam reviews or charts. Why would I trust the collected opinions of one of the most toxic communities on the net?
@Weebleman I wouldn’t worry, it’s just people trying to justify their narrative.
These are the same paid sites that give stuff like EAs other games like fifa 7’s (can’t be paying too well then eh EA?!)
Sadly for many the game has turned out to be pretty good. And those that hadn’t played it and mind their mind up are trying a different tactic.
There has been a toxic narrative about this game before it even came out with far too many 'fans' seemingly wanting it to fail and getting more and more desperate to rubbish any positive takes on it. Sad.
@Ancelyn13
Have you played it? 🤔
@themightyant Sadly this is modern gaming and I wish it wasn't like this. It just sucks the fun out of gaming and gets very tiresome.
Yeah gaming discourse these days just feels very negative, super toxic. Seeing the first post in this thread and the amount of likes it got just makes you sigh. It doesn't shock you anymore, just makes you sad.
I put in my preorder yesterday. Thursday can't come soon enough!!
@freddones Steam reviews are a terrible metric due to the binary Good or Bad system they use. Its about time they shelved it and went to a rating system which reflects the true score.
Why didn't you cover the bigger story of the critics which provide REAL reviews getting their review codes delayed until after all these bribed mainstream got their reviews out. Watch the metacritic user score plummet after a few days. This game and everything about it's content and development is a complete joke. Bioware's been dead for a while. No more of my money is going to them.
@freddones Whilst I agree that reviews on sales platforms should only include people who have bought the game, them buying the game does not make a review more valid than a professional reviewer who received a free copy as part of their job. Sunk cost can impact review bias just as much as zero cost, both negatively and positively depending on the game and the reviewer.
Also it doesn''t adress the fact that Steam reviews are still poor as they simply come down to good game / bad game rather than the more nuanced levels of scoring out of 10 for example.
The amount of time you see reviews of Steam where its 300hrs played and bad game highlights the problem with binary scores. If a game is bad then no one would play it for 300hrs, so clearly it has some redeeming factors.
It is worth mentioning they didn’t provide review codes to anyone who even hinted at criticism during their preview
Concord got similar review scores from the big gaming websites
@Doomcrow both games push the same ideology. On the flip side of the same coin those same sites rated Space Marine 2 lower than it should have been, same reason.
@Doomcrow @Jenkinss SM2 got mostly 8/10s from the major sites, and Concord struggled for anything higher than a 7, so I've no clue what you pair are on about.
@Vordus A game that is clearly GOTY material and a game so bad it was delisted in a week and the entire company shut down - one got 8's on average the other 7's on average, a single point separation. "I have no idea what you are on about" 🤔
Will probably buy my copy, on Xbox, at the end of next month. My Christmas gift to myself.
I have played Dragon Age Inquisition more than I have any other game. So, regardless of the reviews, this is a must buy for me. I shall make up my own mind as to whether I enjoy it or not.
But purely because the PS5 version of Horizon Zero Dawn comes out tomorrow, I have more than enough to keep me busy for the time being.
And I have always found something to enjoy from every BioWare title I have ever played. Even Andromeda.
Okay, maybe not Anthem. That one does not count.
@freddones
People can buy a game, review it badly and then refund it just out of spite.
@freddones
The problem is people doing it when they have no interest in the game at all.
Not buying, playing it and not liking it.
I mean buying it just for the sake of leaving a bad review.
@Jenkinss I said Concord struggled to get anything higher than a seven. It averages out to about a 6.
Regardless, Concord didn't fail because it was bad. Concord failed because it was a middle of the road, me-too overwatch clone in an already crowded genre, offered at a price much more expensive than it's competitors, and marketed extremely poorly. Much worse games have done much better. Not that it's difficult to do better than Concord.
@PsBoxSwitchOwner Exactly. They're paying for these reviews but they happily send their Madden game with the literal billion dollar licence into the wild to get middling reviews every year? Right...
Not everything is a giant conspiracy.
@freddones
Not exceptional cases, I assure you. But that's fine. Believe what you will, it's clear this discussion it's not worth it to either of us.
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...