Talking Point: Should Xbox Start Doing Its Own 'Nintendo Direct' Style Showcases?

It all comes down to having something to show off. You can't have directs if there's no content.

They should try, why not, something new is good.

Absolutely, I'm all in for no filler pure content approach. Unfortunately, it has been mostly opposite with cinematics and hype propaganda.

Not a knock on MS but I would say no as they don't have enough first party content to show, and 3rd parties do a decent job of advertising in other spaces.

Nintendo Directs work in part because of the first party content that Nintendo has but also because Nintendo isn't often put at the forefront of marketing for multiplats or late ports and this gives Nintendo a space to do that instead. So as they say it sends Nintendo info "Directly to You" (when others wont otherwise). A lot of games that are on the switch most users wouldn't know about because they aren't really advertised elsewhere. But the Direct takes care of that (and I suspect also keeps their marketing budget lower as a result. They have TV ads but only for their first party titles really). MS and Sony simply have a different marketing workspace. So the Direct would almost be redundant unless it is about first party or some new MS feature. (same with Sony's State of Play).

I think Microsoft did well with Inside Xbox and X0 pre-pandemic (2018/2019) in terms of style but usually didn't have the content to support it. If 2023 is a strong lineup for Xbox, a return to multiple announcement events per year would work very well.

As a couple others said, only if they have good content to show us. With the lack of big releases this year a direct would be pretty bare.

Well they got 3 big AAA before end of June 2023
So we need some communication and hype building to start soon, in whatever form it takes.

To be honest I don't really care how we learn of games, as far as we have new cool games though.

No. Just no.

Not if it's just going to be them showing trailers for games that are years and years away, have no solid release date at ALL, or don't even have a solid genre nailed down (I'm looking at YOU, Everwild). I don't need more promises of games that are going to come out someday lol

I like the big e3 style show once a year personally. Really glad it's back next year!

I would love more shows from them throughout the year. Yes they didn’t show at the game awards. Waiting till E3 to see something new or updates on games takes forever. More shows would be awesome, but they need to be careful not to show too much or too soon. They had some CGI trailers for many games before the series systems launched. Because many of those games didn’t come out, many feel like Xbox is bad at managing games or that they were delayed. Keeping the cards close and revealing them at appropriate times in multiple shows a year would excite a lot of gaming fans.

I'm surprised at the support. I enjoy the E3 style show, and more importantly, while I liked the Nintendo Direct originally in Iwata's original format, the modern Directs and State of Plays are the most bland pre-recorded dry infomercial nonsense, I might as well be watching an ad for the Pocket Fisherman. They have zero energy and personality, they're literally just a commercial, not a presentation.

I think directs are a bad idea for Xbox at the current time. Last gen was a sales disaster. This gen has not gotten off to a great start for Xbox, with the lack of exclusives, barren 2022, and troubled launches like Halo Infinite. Playstation continues to be the market leader — even by MS's own admission — and Nintendo has found an excellent niche that generates excitement. That's why they've found success with their own directs.

More than anything, I'd argue MS needs to fix the narrative around "Xbox doesn't have any games" which is done by A) Actually releasing exclusives and B) promoting those on broader platforms that have the highest visibility. Directs are fine but they're inevitably preaching to the choir, whereas something like E3 and The Game Awards drives larger viewership. Especially of those who aren't Xbox owners yet but might be.

What's done is done, but showing off something during last week's TGA would have been more effective at driving hardware and GP sales than a direct that's catering to an install base that's already so eager for exclusives that they'll show up regardless. At the very least, they need to balance directs with larger stage events. Maybe big events for announcements and trailers that generate hype, then follow with directs for gameplay deep dives.

I prefer a huge E3. No issue with skipping keighleys shows, he's a hack.

If you want. As long as more and more games are announced:)

Nintendo Direct and PlayStation State of Play are a lot better than E3 type showcases, in my opinion. They are short, sweet, and to the point. I'd like to see Xbox do something similar.

I feel like with the flack they get for the one show (too long, too much cgi, no gameplay, games are too far away, only showing next 12 months means nothing new, etc) they should just focus on perfecting that show first.

In the near future they should start getting regular releases from the array of studios so maybe they will eventually have enough to show at multiple showcases but for now I think the one show plus random spots is all they need.

@BBB One of the issues MS/Xbox ran into this time was that the big 2022 were delayed. Now that they are months away, Spencer/Bond/Howard want to be the ones to debut these games in near finished status. This trio has been involved in pretty much every Xbox show or reveal for the last few years.

@FraserG indies generally dont create excitement.

your average (non gaming site visitor) gamer. dont want to watch budget titles.

they wanna see those AAA blow your socks off bangers.

plus if all you can show are indies, then it shows gaming on your system is poor.

I'm a big fan of Nintendo's style. Only showcase games that are coming out within the next 6ish months. If Fable isn't coming out for 2+ years, I really don't even want to know that it exists.

I've wanted this from Microsoft for a while and somewhat surprised it hasn't happened.

they do poor job promoting stuff games just get dumped on gamepass and they are never heard of again

I'd rather they put out teasers when games are truly close to release. Don't try to tease me for months on end for a game clearly not ready yet.

I'd like to think they learned to wait and not over promise.

As well as needing to publicise what is coming in 2023 and beyond, MS has a really bad track record with marketing. They should be pushing the games they do have even if it is a bit weak right now. Additions to gamepass should be publicised everywhere, same with making things like ID@Xbox more accessible. Not just for people like us who frequent pure xbox, ign, kinda funny etc but let the masses know about exclusive or AAA games on Xbox.

The studios under Xbox banner need to put out those sweet trailers. Whether you release those trailers in E3, or TGA or Gamescom or direct is just a matter of when they press play on those videos. The content needs to come from studios. It will only happen when they have strict deadlines. Teams left to "take their time" will probably take a very slow pace for developing their games.

X/S could be 4 or 5 years old by the time they get a decent cadence of 1st party games. GamePass is good but I didn't pay for a console and a fast storage card just for indies and 3rd party stuff I could have played on a Playstation. Really enjoyed Guardians of the Galaxy though, not gonna lie.