Comments 2,756

Re: Forza On PS5 Has 'Easily' Made $100 Million For Xbox, Says Analyst

BacklogBrad

If xbox continues to demonstrate that this much money is being left on the table then sony and nintendo execs will have a harder time keeping their games exclusive to one platform. It's hard to imagine a future where playstation games are not releasing on Nintendo and maybe even xbox (if xbox goes the pc route then it might not be up to sony).

It's been a slow death for exclusives but it looks like it's just a matter of time.

Re: Xbox Is Giving Away Deathloop For Free, But Only The PC Version

BacklogBrad

Deathloop was already an epic store giveaway. This is the second time they have had it as a freebie.

The outer worlds, Elder scrolls online, the evil within 1&2, wolfenstein new order, prey, ghostwire tokyo, dishonored/dishonored death of outsider and every fallout except 4 were also an epic freebie.

I'm not sure about the pillars of eternity ip ownership but that was a giveaway too. Epic giveaways are great and bethesda has given away pretty much their whole catalog there, most of them after xbox bought them.

Re: Xbox Dominates PS5 Charts, Forza Horizon 5 'Most Downloaded' Game In May

BacklogBrad

@Millionski i think the next step for xbox and playstation is to move beyond just the box in the living room. Xbox has play anywhere and are going more towards a pc based system. Sony is rumored to be working on a pc store with cross entitlements similar to play anywhere. You can still buy the box if you want to, but they need to expand beyond that as the only place to play their games.

I believe the industry is much worse if you need to buy box A to play this set of games and box B to play that set of games. It's annoying to have all those different boxes and libraries if you can afford them and prohibitive to those that can't afford all of them.

Re: Xbox Dominates PS5 Charts, Forza Horizon 5 'Most Downloaded' Game In May

BacklogBrad

@Xboxian360 if exclusives were the reason to buy an Xbox, no one would have ever bought an Xbox to begin with. They went decades with very little first party support. 1st party content was their greatest weakness until the last 2 years.

There are about to be more xbox hardware devices available than any other generation. There will be the Microsoft devices, officially licensed 3rd party devices and probably a more fleshed out xbox environment on pc. You are also ignoring that Nintendo and Steam compete head to head with Sony already and will continue to do so. It will be even more so when Steam's "home console" device comes out and other pc companies release their own "console" pc like they did with handhelds. Sony has never seen more competition than they are right now. Xbox isn't going anywhere but Sony wouldn't have anything close to a monopoly if they did.

You seem to be making the same mistake the FTC made when they tried to redefine what the industry is. The companies are evolving beyond the single home device restriction and the industry will be better for it.

Exclusives do nothing but make it harder for people to buy and play the game.

Re: Xbox Building A Handheld 'Makes No Sense', Says Former Blizzard Boss

BacklogBrad

I want them to lean into the xbox is a pc strategy. So a handheld that only has xbox store/interface is not something i want. Hopefully they get windows into a more gaming focused state. It seems like steamOS is lighting a fire inside microsoft and showing them that default windows is not the best choice for every device. They need a version with no bloat and is gaming focused.

Steam deck kind of already has the solution with the desktop mode as a separate thing to use for the computing side of setting it up and the gaming mode for ease of use/console feel.

Re: Sony Has Approached Subscriptions 'Healthier' Than Xbox, Says Former PlayStation Boss

BacklogBrad

As a consumer, I view the gamepass model as far superior. I do not want the company to force me to buy the game at full price or subscribe to a monthly service to get access to that game in the distant future. Xbox gives the consumer the decision, buy to own or play it with a subscription. Pro tip - buy 1 month of gamepass, use %20 discount to purchase to own a couple games the savings will be more than the month of gamepass so you save money and get 1 month of gp access.

By "healthier" he really means less appealing. FOMO/exclusion is the only card Sony plays. Now that Sony releases are so few and far between, what will ever make their subscription appealing?

Re: Microsoft Celebrates As Xbox Vs. FTC Officially Comes To An End

BacklogBrad

I am always glad to see the FTC defeated. It is a completely flawed agency in need of major reform. Now they need to drop the case vs Meta/Facebook. The FTC is using the same flawed narrow market definitions they used against xbox. They claim Facebook does not compete with TikTok or youtube because those are "video sharing sites" not family/friend based social media. I hate meta/facebook but that is crazy to suggest they dont compete with tiktok or yt. Just like suggesting xbox doesn't compete with Nintendo or steam was crazy.

The FTC also categorized Kroger grocery stores as "traditional grocery stores" so that they could make the claim that Kroger does not compete with walmart, costco, amazon etc. It is insane to claim walmart and costco do not compete with grocery stores. It blows my mind that they were successful in blocking a Kroger merger.

Re: Atomfall Was 'Immediately Profitable' Despite Launching On Xbox Game Pass

BacklogBrad

I don't think people realize how many sales it takes to offset the upfront money a gamepass deal provides.

According to a leak, xbox expects big AAA games on day 1 to require $100M to $300M. At $70 per game, that is 1.4 million to 4.3 million copies. Doom the dark ages is at 3 million players even with gamepass.

Publishers don't care if gamepass reduces their sales totals because odds are the up front amount more than covered whatever dip in sales it caused. Plus gamepass is only a temporary rental where the gp players might buy the game to keep later.

Re: Xbox & Bethesda Say DOOM: The Dark Ages Is id Software's 'Biggest Launch' Ever

BacklogBrad

Don't worry the "this is doing poorly" narrative won't go away. They will just blame it on gamepass as if thats a negative for the game. If anything that is better for xbox than a one time purchase but those doom (pun) and gloomers refuse to believe that. It would be interesting to see a breakdown of where pc gamers are for this game. If pc gamepass/playanywhere has more Doom DA players than Steam, I think that would be a huge deal and a big win for xbox.

I am going back to enjoying the game. Doom on.

Re: Poll: What Do You Think Of DOOM: The Dark Ages So Far?

BacklogBrad

It's a great game but it's my least favorite of the recent trilogy. I replayed Eternal directly before diving into this one and that game is better in almost every way. Still a great game though and I really enjoy it. I think I'm settling on a score around 8 to 8.5.

We had double jump and dozens of unique glory kills, we had it all.

Re: Xbox's 2027 Handheld Expected To Include Nintendo Switch-Like Docking System

BacklogBrad

@acmiguens I don't think ps6 and the Series X successor will be much more powerful than current systems (but they will be expensive).

I also don't think there will be many (if any) games next gen that cannot run on ps5/ series x. They will run better on ps6 and nexbox but i think the days of games being flat out unable to run on the previous gen are just about over. If developers are targeting the widest audience possible then they will continue to target mid range pcs/switch/switch2/ps5 and maybe even ps4. A series x level handheld would miss out on single digit (likely zero) games that the series x successor has. Just like how the series s still has not missed out on anything the series x offers except split screen for baldurs gate 3 for a brief period.

Games have hit a plateau. Developers pushing limits of hardware are rare and getting rarer.

Re: Talking Point: Do You Feel You've Had Value For Money With Your Xbox Series X|S?

BacklogBrad

Even though PC has been my go-to since before this gen released, I feel like owning both series x and s has been well worth it.

I plan to continue pairing the future xbox consoles with pc. Having gamepass ultimate makes them a perfect pairing. It still blows my mind how seamless it is to pick up from the same save on my consoles, desktop, handheld, cloud, etc. Transferring a save on 2 Playstation or 2 Nintendo devices feels like outdated tech compared to xbox.

Re: Xbox Seemingly Affected As Microsoft Announces Thousands More Job Cuts

BacklogBrad

It sounds like it's centered on management positions so it doesn't sound like its whole teams getting let go. It probably won't affect xbox too much from a project standpoint.

The large bank i work at does this too. They promote a ton of people after they have been there awhile to manage small teams. Then they realize there are way too many small teams and eliminate managers to consolidate to larger teams. Then the process ends up repeating a few years later.

Re: Talking Point: Xbox Fans, How Many Of You Are Buying A Switch 2?

BacklogBrad

I was on the fence for launch before the price announcement but have decided to wait and see. I will probably end up with one someday but from what I have seen so far, I don't think I will be missing anything if I never get one.

They need to prove to me that the price increases are justified. I found the switch 1 to be a neat curiosity at first but that quickly wore off. I haven't wanted to play it for a few years now. I don't know what the switch 2 can do to seem appealing to me but I know they haven't shown that yet.

I believe nintendo is the worst platform to buy or play 3rd party games on so it comes down to if i find enough exclusives interesting to justify the $450 +$80 x each game. So far, zero games fit that bill for me.

Re: Oblivion Remastered's Performance 'Degrades' Over Time, Digital Foundry Discovers

BacklogBrad

I have heard from friends having major issues with crashes later in the game on series x. I still haven't had a crash on xbox pc app but I am not anywhere near late game with my 10 hours. Performance hasnt been great even without full crashes.
I am juggling a ton of games right now and this one might take a back seat until I am a little more confident there won't be issues.

Hopefully Doom is ready for my no life playthrough.