
Xbox has suffered a blow this week, as the U.S. Federal Trade Commission has announced that Microsoft has been forced to pay $20 million for a privacy breach involving children's personal information.
In the FTC's press release, it's explained that Microsoft "violated the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) by collecting personal information from children who signed up to its Xbox gaming system without notifying their parents or obtaining their parents’ consent, and by illegally retaining children’s personal information."
As a result, Microsoft is being required to abide by the following rules moving forward:
- Inform parents who have not created a separate account for their child that doing so will provide additional privacy protections for their child by default;
- Obtain parental consent for accounts created before May 2021 if the account holder is still a child;
- Establish and maintain systems to delete, within two weeks from the collection date, all personal information that it collects from children for the purposes of obtaining parental consent if it has not obtained parental consent and to delete all other personal data collected from children after it is no longer necessary to fulfill the purpose for which it was collected; and
- Notify video game publishers when it discloses personal information from children that the user is a child, which will require the publishers to apply COPPA’s protections to that child.
Xbox has responded to the FTC's order, explaining that the team has "children’s safety and privacy top of mind", and that the account creation process now requires anyone under the age of 13 to obtain verified parental consent.
"Regrettably, we did not meet customer expectations and are committed to complying with the order to continue improving upon our safety measures. We believe that we can and should do more, and we’ll remain steadfast in our commitment to safety, privacy, and security for our community."
It's also mentioned that a "technical glitch" was behind the retention of certain child account data, and this has since been fixed. Microsoft says the data was "never used, shared, or monetised".
"During the investigation, we identified a technical glitch where our systems did not delete account creation data for child accounts where the account creation process was started but not completed. This was inconsistent with our policy to save that information for only 14 days to make it easier for gamers to pick up where they left off to complete the process.
Our engineering team took immediate action: we fixed the glitch, deleted the data, and implemented practices to prevent the error from recurring. The data was never used, shared, or monetized."
The rest of Xbox's response goes into detail about how the team plans to "remain steadfast in our commitment to safety, privacy, and security for our community", which includes testing new methods to validate age in the future. The Microsoft Privacy Statement has also been updated with the last information about "how Xbox processes user data.
"We want all parents, caregivers, and families to know that, more than anything else, we have their children’s safety and privacy top of mind. We will continue to communicate the changes we are making to our practices and the data we collect so we can better protect children using our platform. We also continue to explore creative ways to educate players about online safety."
If you want to read the full Xbox response to the FTC, you'll find it on the official Xbox Wire website.
What do you make of this? Let us know down in the comments section below.
[source news.xbox.com]
Comments 33
Honestly, I think this is kind of stupid. Doesn't a kid simply have to click that they are over 13 to make an account without consent? It's not like these companies are checking ID's at the door. But hey, this is the government we're talking about, they're here to help us. /s
Meanwhile, all those 13 year olds that have cell phones.....
@SplooshDmg it’s pretty much a honor system, I think.
I do am curious how they got caught, though. They claim to have never used the information, and seems ir only happened to accounts that didn’t actually finish creation… so how did they get caught? Someone tested half creating an account and came back a year later to see the half-created account still there? Got email reminders to finish account creation?
@Tharsman Maybe little Billy/Suzie tried creating an account under their parent's nose, got caught, and parent blamed Microsoft for simply allowing this to happen and turned them in to the authorities.
Loving the automatic defending of MS versus the online safety of children!
Guessing not many here will have kids of their own. The amount of effort that most parents actually go through to try and keep gaming safe - its surprisingly tiring work!
Having all of the 3 major consoles, so having to have a different passcode for all accounts, setting up age restrictions, time limits then having to block accounts for all of them as punishments, then reactivate etc!! Can't wait for them to be old enough to not bother anymore 🤣
MS probably deserved a bigger 'slap on the legs' than they got - however would imagine they do see safety as a major issue and this hopefully means they are a lot more focussed on getting it right.
@StonyKL Completely agree!
Also it's a paltry fine for MS/Xbox and only encourages them to keep playing fast and loose with the rules and take the slap-on-the-wrist/fine later.
@StonyKL ah, the guy who constantly criticises xbox is criticising xbox haha
This doesn't sound like an XboX issue, more of a parental issue.
Also, EVERY company keeps info on EVERYONE! Kids included.
Heck, the government itself does as well.
And before anyone says "but they don't use it" that's a lie.
Selective Service
Medical records
And a bunch of other stuff I won't go in to
@StonyKL I’d say it’s pretty clear most of the people here don’t have kids.
@FatalBubbles
I have three.
@StonyKL Another agree here as well.
I'm thinking many of these comments are from people who don't have children (but have plenty of opinions on raising them, of course!) mixed with diehard company loyalty.
In the end this is a best-case scenario for MS: a VERY light fine (that's pocket change for one of the world's biggest megacorps) while shining a light on a loophole that they needed to close to keep kids safe going forward. MS got off easy and got to fix the problem.
I don't understand how anyone could see this as a bad thing.
Parent gamers sound the worse
@Zoidpilot4 Pretty sure I didn't criticize Xbox. Think I only made a dig at was people blaming children/parents for the mistakes made by Microsoft who acknowledged their errors and vowed to improve themselves? And also nothing wrong with making mistakes and improving which was what I was sort of implying with my last statement.
Edit: I also think parent gamers are the best! We lived the golden generations of gaming with such classics as Wolf 3D, Doom, Half Life, Mario, Sonic, Street Fighter 2 (I could go on of course) and get to bore our kids about how much better gaming was in 'those' days
Personally, I think it should be up to the parents to ensure their children only have access to accounts set up for them with the appropriate parental controls and carry out regular checks to ensure they're not doing things they shouldn't be.
@StonyKL I played all those games, all those consoles, I'm 32 years old. But kids? I couldn't cope. Sorry, the gamer parents are the worst was a joke, as was the other comment. I got autism. My apoligies. Usually my wife translates for me in real life haha
I showed my nephew Morrwind and he told me it was the worst graphics in the world. So I showed him Heroes of might and magic. Now he thinks I'm ancient haha
@Zoidpilot4 no worries I didn't take any offense , hence my joke response back but I do get annoyed with the kids not appreciating the classics! Although I get the same problem when getting the kids to watch Back to the Future, Indiana Jones, Goonies! They just don't appreciate real quality 😂😂
@StonyKL It's depressing ain't it haha.
Good to see people defend Microsoft eh?!
Other companies manage not to gather the data of children.
Nothing to do with parents, it’s about Microsoft obtaining data they should not have.
@Utena-mobile
Gathering data on anyone sucks, regardless of age.
Disgusting from the FTC. Xbox should pull all their products from the corrupt USA….
Xbox did nothing wrong. They never can do wrong.
@LoquaciousB do you have kids and how old are they?
Do you think we should have any laws and protections?
Seatbelts?
Drinking age?
Surely parents can make sure kids don’t drink until they should?
Everyone should want to wear a seat belt so why have a law?
Protections exist for a reason.
Don’t wish away protections
@FatalBubbles this for sure and also most people just don’t understand the principle of why we have laws and protections.
@Zoidpilot4 says a guy that will defend anything Xbox do.
@Stocksy too late. Nice try, but if you read the comments you'd see why your comment makes no sense. Good job baiting tho. Well done. Cool cool.
@Stocksy First of all, I won't be answering any of your questions about my family. Such a creepy thing to ask a complete stranger on the Internet.
Secondly, stop being so hyperbolic, as you just come off as completely ridiculous. The other things you mentioned are in no way analogous to this whatsoever.
Yes, laws are there to protect people but parental complacency is a massive factor. I'm not absolving Xbox for their failings here, I'm pointing out that parents have primary responsibility for overseeing the online safety of their children.
@Spider-Kev This is the only correct answer. Once you hit the ripe ole age of 13, you get the honor to finally become corporate cannon fodder. Oh, boy!
@LoquaciousB I've learnt that it's best to not feed the dogmatic agents of negativity. He makes assumptions based on his narrow minded views, can't argue or reason with someone who believes their opinions are superior. Also, I get the impression he isn't interested in having a non bias conversation. He just wants to bait others into a confrontation. Sad when you think about it. Imagine having that mindset where you actively seek out arguments
@Kaloudz thanks hahah =)
Fining Microsoft $20,000,000 is like fining me $2,000. Nothing of serious consequence.
Do they keep all the money to themselves or share it with all the parents?
@InterceptorAlpha wish i had $2000 to not miss... seriously, if i had £20 (uk!) i'd be happy
@Porridge2215 I'd miss it. But at the end of the day, wouldn't really be a punishment or anything because I'd make it back before too long. That's essentially what it is like living with US "Healthcare", so we're just kinda used to it
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...