
Back in December, it was revealed that a group of 10 "gamers" were filing a private consumer antitrust lawsuit against Microsoft's attempt to acquire Activision Blizzard, and Microsoft has recently been trying to pause that suit.
The reason? Microsoft's lawyers have suggested that the company's (and Activision Blizzard's) ongoing issues with the FTC could result in this private case causing "needless and duplicative litigation and the risk of inconsistent rulings".
Unfortunately for Microsoft, U.S. District Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley of San Francisco denied this request last week, stating that she will hear a bid from the gamers for a preliminary injunction on March 23rd, 2023.
Here's what a Microsoft spokesperson had to say following the ruling (thanks Reuters):
"We remain confident in our case and path forward and are committed to closing the deal."
The lawsuit from these Plaintiffs argues that the games industry could suffer "extensive and broad" damage due to the "merging of two giants", warning that if it goes through, "Microsoft may have far-outsized market power".
We'll keep you up to date as we hear more about this lawsuit over the next couple of months.
What do you make of this? Let us know down in the comments section below.
[source reuters.com]
Comments 25
I really wonder if Microsoft is thinking to themselves "Maybe this wasn't really worth all this headache."
10 very sad losers
These 10 are the epitome of no lifers...cringe how sad
What a world, 10 literal salty spiteful Sony PlayStation fans suing the competition purely because they want to buy a third party studio, exactly the same actions Sony takes. And the courts allow it… who will be their Defence for when Sony performs the exact same actions? Pathetic.
For a moment I thought we were getting Ace Attorney 4-6
@S1ayeR74 'purely because they want to buy a third party studio, exactly the same actions Sony takes.' I'm sorry but Sony doesnt buy huge publishers like activision , sure they bought bungie but they've only been an independent publisher for a few years & have been owned by both Microsoft & Activision before that & have a grand total of 1 IP 😂
@S1ayeR74 I mean it’s not exactly the same actions is it? Combine ALL of Sonys acquisitions over the years and they probably come to about £20billion (the actual figure is likely way less but I’m accounting for inflation). MS is stumping up over three times that for one acquisition.
This is also hot on the heels of another massive acquisition (Bethesda) which will see PlayStation players locked out of a number of hugely popular future releases which they will almost certainly have been able to play if not for the takeover. It just doesn’t sit right with alot of the gaming community because it doesn’t feel like MS is creating anything, they are just buying up as much stuff as possible that already exists.
As an owner of both consoles and a gamepass subscriber I am lucky enough to be in the position where I will get to play all these games but a lot of people aren’t in a position where they can buy both. When you buy a PS5 you know your not going to be able to play Halo, Forza, Fable and Gears of war but 3 years ago no one expected to be locked out of future editions of franchises like Elder scrolls, Doom, Wolfenstein, Tony hawks, crash bandicoot, Fallout which have an established multi platform history. That’s not to mention new IPs like Starfield and Redfall and who knows for sure about the future of COD.
I think some people here just need to take a step back and imagine how they would be reacting if Sony had just bought Bethesda and were on the cusp of buying Activision. I reckon the comments would be just as, if not more “salty” as what your getting from PS players at the moment.
@Would_you_kindly Sony HAS bought Studios though, Insomniac as an example. And that’s a fact, hence my comment, size was irrelevant, plus MS has stated over and over and over it is NOT locking down COD, apart from Bungie all of Sonys studios make PS exclusive games, and then another seems to port them to PC over a year later.
Hopefully, Microsoft counter sues them. So sick of frivolous lawsuits...
@GeeEssEff If this was Sony buying Activision Sony fans would literally be screaming for COD and every single other game to be made completely PS exclusive, they would more then likely call up and threaten Sony execs if they weren’t, they get upset at the thought of other platforms playing their games, hell I’ve seen some cry when PC ports have been announced, not joking.
Sony may not have acquired studios as big as this buyout, but they have acquired them and let’s not ignore the other business practices Sony employs to lock down content and keep it off other platforms.
Still doesn’t change the fact these 10 are salty PS fanboys.
@S1ayeR74 'apart from Bungie all of Sonys studios make PS exclusive games, and then another seems to port them to PC over a year later.' none of those games except destiny were ever multiplatform to begin with you could make an argument about Spider-Man but marvel approached Microsoft before insomniac so if they hadn't declined it would've been exclusive anyway just to Xbox instead of playstation
@Would_you_kindly Yeah, you just repeated what I said….
Of course it's not "10 people suing", 10 people wouldn't have the money to file frivolous suits against one of the 5 richest companies on earth.
The question that matters is: Who's backing them? Could be Sony, could be the government, could be a foreign government, could be lawyers looking for a quick buck....could be a lot of things. But someone's bankrolling a lawsuit that will cost tens of millions, unless one of these people is Elon Musk or Jim Ryan.
And Jim couldn't even afford it on his own. And it's not Tencent. As one of ABK's largest shareholders, Tencent makes big bank from this deal and loses money if it doesn't.
@OrfeasDourvas
Same! So dissapointed.
@S1ayeR74 just to be clear I’m not defending the 10 people with this lawsuit. I think it’s a pointless waste of time although I agree with the overall sentiment. Also while you’re correct there likely would be some Sony fans requesting exclusivity it’s unfair to tarnish every PS owner with the same brush. Fanboys will be fanboys…ironically it very much feels like I’m talking to one now.
Would_you_kindly has already stated Xbox had first dibs on Spider-Man but I think it’s also worth mentioning that Insomniac have a long long history with Sony dating back to before the Xbox was even a twinkle in Bill Gates eye. Sony assisted in the development of both Spyro and Resistance which is why they were exclusive. Had Xbox not turned down Spider-Man Sony probably wouldn’t currently own them.
If by “other business practices” you mean exclusivity windows well it might shock you to learn that MS and Nintendo do it as well. I am currently playing Rogue Legacy 2 which isn’t made by an MS studio but isn’t on PS. Tunic last year came out about 6 months ahead of PlayStation. I mean literally last month High on Life came out exclusively for xbox….I’m sorry which MS owned studio developed that? You accuse Sony of stuff which is industry wide all the while forgetting you’re championing a company which has some pretty shady business practices in its history and is, as we speak, in the process of sacking 10,000 employees on the back of a $80billion profit year all while trying to buy another company for $69billion
I hope they secure the bag. Love me a good underdog story.
Imagine being one of these losers, like you gotta be the worst example of a "gamer." Loser is the only accurate way to describe them as well, because they are guaranteed to lose. I hope Microsoft bankrupts them in court.
@Trmn8r What pisses me off about these people is the audacity of how they act like they represent everyone. They couldn't be further from representing me. Just total narcissists who think the entire industry needs to revolve around their nonsense.
@JayJ They are just opportunists hoping to get settlement money. Frivolous lawsuits are a big problem in the US. People need to stop settling and start countersuing.
I bet they've never played halo that's for sure, precious playstation user.
Why are so many people in the comments over here so obsessed with sony some of you sound pathetic.
@GeeEssEff You are deliberately being ignorant of the history of Sony and exclusives. This is an Xbox site, shock horror it has Xbox fans here.
And yes I do have owned PS and Switch, you seem to be against this deal, you state you agree with the sentiment of these 10 people, the majority believe the court won't and will throw it out.
And then you attempt to use the reduction of MS staff as a weapon in your argument, when it has absolutely nothing to do with the story. Also FYI ALL big tech companies have laid staff off recently as they are not needed.
I think we know your angle, you seem to be picking on MS here and criticisms them regardless. Using tactics unrelated to the story makes that a suspicion.
You may not be defending these 10 people, but your certainly seem to sympathises with them and enjoy criticising Microsoft whilst defending Sony in your comments.
Sony ponies will do anything to make Xbox look bad.
@Rangers420 Probably because Sony has been the primary force pushing opposition to this deal mr 420. A better question is why are you on an Xbox site trying to defend them?
@JayJ For starters I'm not defending sony both companies are scummy and people acting like ms are some small company being bullied by evil sony is hilarious and also what does this specific lawsuit filled by 10 nobody's have to do with sony?.
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...