
The fact that we get ads on the Xbox dashboard doesn't come as a surprise these days, but a new ad for McDonald's has attracted a bit of controversy - with almost half a million people viewing a complaint about it on social media.
On the likes of "X" and Reddit, we've seen irritations that Microsoft is advertising things beyond gaming on Xbox's UI, with the most popular argument being that "non game-related stuff can get in the bin". Here's a look at some examples:
In general, it feels like most people in the comments have been siding with this complaint, although others claim that people are worrying too much and have pointed out that Microsoft even employed these tactics in the Xbox 360 era.
However you feel about it, clearly this new McDonalds ad has hit a sore spot with certain members of the Xbox community, and we're assuming Microsoft will have taken note of the controversy. Whether that'll change anything remains to be seen, but to be honest we think that ads will become more commonplace rather than less in the future.
Do Ads Like This Bother You On The Xbox Dashboard? (1,385 votes)
- Yes, there's no place for stuff like this!
- Not a major problem, but it does bother me
- It's kind of annoying I guess...?
- Not really, but I'd rather it wasn't there
- Who cares?! This is a non-issue!
Does this kind of thing bother you, or is everyone fussing about nothing? Tell us in the poll and comments.
Comments 73
The people voting "who cares" or "not really" are the reason this is only going to get worse.
We'll have ads in loading screens, and pause menus soon enough, and then unskippable ads during system boot, and during game launch, then in-between rounds of multiplayer games. And on and on it goes.
The 360 Pizza Hut app to Backwards Compatibility confirmed!
The advertisements, in general, can go, though I know they won't. I can deal with the game or console-related ones because those make sense. Mickey D's ads, though... nope. It's a shame a perk of the highest game pass tier doesn't include not seeing these non Xbox-related ads.
@user0 at the point it gets in the way with any game then I will care. And by care I mean not play the game & blacklist the publisher / Devs involved.
This doesn't interfere and I barely notice anything on the dashboard or spend anytime on it as it is.
Honestly got more important things to worry right now that a few ads I barely see.
I don't spend too much time on the dashboard but I'm completely against practices like this. If I'm paying for something I don't want to see any ads. That same thinking goes for any subscription services I have like Netflix, Prime Video and others
You pay a premium to be part of an eco system so there shouldn't be adds of anytype on any intro dashboard. Even game offers should be limited to when you are in the store, or on the store part of the dash.
This is basic and should apply to all platforms.
I begrudgingly tolerate the gaming/entertainment related ads there, but fast food adverts are so unclassy and slimy. Really sullies the Xbox experience, makes it feel cheap and nasty. If you must advertise at least keep it related to products and services that you can access on the actual Xbox itself, or Xbox related accessories. Microsoft should be reminded that their competitors don’t steep to these lows, which just leads to Xbox feeling like cheap tat vs Steam, PlayStation, Nintendo. Do better Xbox.
If I see this on my dashboard I’ll be reporting my dissatisfaction to Microsoft for sure.
I don’t want any ads. The Switch doesn’t have ads and neither should any platform.
I pay for Ultimate this should be entirely add free. You know what even if i didn’t put adds in the store and take it out of my dashboard. I struggle so hard watching the olympics with all the adds. I only watch what i want on physical or streaming with no adds.
Completely unacceptable. We need to stop normalising the intrusion of advertising everywhere in our lives. And, you wouldn't get this on the PS5 or Switch...
Unacceptable but then again nearly everything Microsoft and xbox does now is Unacceptable
That’s not a bad deal £2.79 for breakfast deal 🤫
Removed - trolling/baiting
It's completely the same to me. For me, it's as relevant as a COD ad.
I mean, it's awful but I kinda want ms to be making whatever they can from Xbox right now.
I guess people forget that MS have been doing this for decades. The 360 dashboard was polluted with non gaming ads. Especially when the 'Metro' box dashboard came along. It was full of this crap, back then they were auto play flash video ads with the volume set to 100 decibels.
Everything from Lynx/Axe deodorant to pet insurance and bananas. They ran a fish finger ad for months here in the UK. Complaining didn't work then, it won't now.
Don't get why people get upset over these 🤣 who even looks at em 🤣😭
Cant stand it. For me, its another reason to ditch xbox. My choice, please dont be offended, I respect your choices too.
@Aniscape That's not happening. Even cable TV has ads.
@user0
I voted non issue because there are already ads on the home screen which I ignore. What they are advertising - the ad content - is irrelevant to me. I'm slightly more likely to go to McDonald's than play COD, honestly,
so I guess I prefer it, even. Placement creeping into other area is a different issue
I do agree that aggressive marketing and inserting ads everywhere as a general thing is bad. But I did not see that in the question
All just so in the next 12months they can charge us more for an advert free tier.
I don't like the ads in general considering I paid full price for the Xbox and they snuck the bulk of em in with a forced system update a year or two after launch.
Typically I wouldn't have batted an eye at a McDonald's advert but currently having a bit of a moment in my battle against food addiction, I feel this is a pretty lame advert for a moderately unhealthy and addictive food.
If I could, I would be fairly in favour of a ban on adverts for junk/fast food as well as alcohol and f2p games. I am 100% in favour of a ban on adverts for gambling. They've banned smoking adverts so I'd like to see the same applied for other industries that rely on addiction for custom.
To be clear, I do not support the banning of the thing itself because it's up to individuals to decide what they do with their health, money and life. By the same token, I would be in favour of legalising certain recreational drugs.
However, I don't think people need to be bombarded with encouragement in the form of adverts that have been specially designed from years of experience and research in how to best liberate people of their money. I would be in favour of the opposite though, i.e. educational resources on diet, addiction etc.
Removed - discussing moderation
I am too busy having fun playing games to worry about such a tiny little ad that I didn't even notice. Such first world problems.
Broadly against the psychological warfare that is modern marketing, and inserting it into paid products, let alone everywhere else.
Also confused as to how advertising is seen as so valuable companies throw so much money at it at all. Marketing budgets are so inflated, to the point that companies make more money selling ad space than actually charging for products. Advertising is massively overvalued and is a massive part of why most goods and services are far overpriced, it's the marketing, not the product, you're buying. (ignoring the PS advertising vs Xbox having none being a problem.)
And surprised that people are taking notice and exception to a McDonald's ad now. I distinctly remember Dorito's ads, Old Spice, Axe, TLoU TV show, all very much not Xbox or gaming related. This isn't new. It's hideous but not new.
I wouldn't have even noticed this ad or thought anything about it if people weren't making a fuss over it. Couldn't care less.
The Adbox is living up to its nickname.
I have a huge problem with all the ads. I don't see the game ads any differently or any better than a McDonalds ad, it's all obtrusive BS that takes up my dashboard. The idea that this is SUDDENLY a problem because of of McDonalds is what is wrong here.
I don't mind the ads to be honest anything that keeps gamepass costing more is a good thing
I'm paying top dollar for Xbox ultimate and they're still plastering ads on the home screen to get a few more bucks.
Announcing new games, etc. I'll live with, but for food, or breakdown insurance they can get lost.
As long as it is on the dashboard I don't care. I spend zero time on the dashboard as I go straight to games or load the last game I played. I certainly don't pay attention to whoever has paid Microsoft to shove things down my throat, literally in this case.
Nothing new. The original Transformer and Transformer 2 for the x360 had in game adds which added ads inside the game, while you were online. I believe it was the same for the ps3 version.
Christ, that's tacky. Being a primarily Nintendo person thankfully shields me from a lot of this.
There should be no ads on the dashboard at all
We had it on the Xbox 360. It’s really not an issue.
@somnambulance yes, but the Switch has done well 👀
They have had pringles adds in the past that I noticed that wanted you to watch the add so you were in with a chance of winning something like £5 store credit or something so it's hardly the first time they have had ads for things like that on the dashboard. I would be more concerned that the person still has Christmas ornaments under their TV in August.
Can we take a quick moment here: how does that ad work? Like what happens when you click on it? Does Xbox have a McDonalds app? Does it pull up a QR code for you to download on your phone? I don't even understand what this is doing?
On the issue of ads, yes this is just the next step to even more intrusive ones. And they are moving pretty quickly. In just the last year they have added:
Boot up ads first for first party games, starting with Starfield (I was personally ok with this)
Boot up ads for their Developer_Direct and Showcase (this was a little more concerning, since it's kinda an ad for a longer ad)
Boot up ad for their Summer Sale (this is over the line, because there are weekly sales, and more ads are definitely coming)
Non-gaming ads being accepted is pretty much the floodgates opening. If I had to guess, we are probably about two years away from a boot up ad every time you you turn on your Xbox, and anything will be on the table
Yet the changes the friend list being disorganised unlike before section with what everyone is playing
if they want to have stuff about games fine. This is a no go for me though we pay for the box we pay for the multiplayer i think we should have some say about what we see. I am calling it now next gamepass tier 29.99 the no adds tier.
@InvaderFromSpace They put ads into Windows 11's Start Menu, ad didn't back down even with uproar. I don't give it 2 years. Microsoft wants to be Google selling ads through everything.
@Zenszulu " I would be more concerned that the person still has Christmas ornaments under their TV in August."
I mean, you'll just have to put them up again in less than a year. Why bother taking them down?
All the complaints tells them that people saw the ad and that is all the matters when it comes to advertising. We will be seeing much more advertising in the future.
Well MS has to off set the lack of games sales somewhere. 🤷♂️
Yeah, non related ads in particular on something you've paid for is taking the p!ss.
And food ads at that! I'm trying to lose some weight, stop putting food in my mind already...sneaky advertisers.
@Dan1283 I am super done with Xbox after this gen. They lured us in with nostalgia and big spend but the user experience hasn't gotten better. Backwards compatibility stopped, games barely run 4K and 120fps let alone their joke marketing of 8K, and they don't know how to manage studios to make great gameplay. Tango works did Hifi Rush and was canned. Back to Nintendo and their focus on the player.
@Mustoe I half agree, except when the console alternative is PayStation: For the Payers, feels like kind of a magic coin toss for the biggest tossers really.
There's PC, of course, but then we're the biggest losers. Jensen needs a new $5m leather jacket made of gamer centipede.
I'd prefer a McDonalds ad over the Take 5 oil change ad I get.
More e-waste, straight to your eyes. Everywhere. A new form of pollution.
This is why I tapped out of the Series X and running down my GPU sub on PC. Unbelievable. 😭
“Baba, baba, baa! Done with it!”
This makes me look even more forward to Switch 2 & PS6/PS5 pro
@Doomcrow You are always leaving Xbox.
@NEStalgia it was a tongue in cheek comment I wasn't being serious
@Markatron84 Yeah, but it followed the WiiU. If a platform wants to advertise McDonalds, at least toss McKids on the console or something.
@fbnaulin
The year is 2034. My primary console is the Xbox 720 Series X One. Really looking forward to the Switch 3 & Ps7 😂
@Mustoe True to a point but also talking about one in a vacuum like that's the bad one and the others are good ones misses a lot of context
@Mustoe again I agree, and we agree they're both just as bad, but I think the impression of coming on an Xbox site to badmouth Xbox exclusively creates the impression of console warring in favor of other brands when those brands are in fact also bad. Is not about defending Xbox because others are bad it's about not creating the image that others are good because Xbox is bad. "Xbox bad" instantly reads to most as "ps better".
I never go below the opening dashboard so i don’t really see ads. That being said I avoid the lower parts of the dashboard for that reason. Switching back to PC as my HDbox next gen.
@WhiteRabbit 100%. The Game Pass Tears keep coming!
They should get rid of the adds in total, it takes up vital space , on XBOX one i could list in groups my various games.
Having six or so groups . on Series consoles I get two , because the rest is Microsoft trying to sell me stuff.
For gods sake I bought the console, bought the games. ruining my dashboard with pointless adds drives me mad.
I've never seen an ad on my dashboard (other than gaming which is expected) so it must be a regional thing. I guess one benefit of living in a s**th*le country like mine lol.
Why no option for NO ADS at all?
Maybe I'm in the minority of people that feel this way but if your paying any kind of premium subscription then you shouldn't have ads on your premium service or product. So Microsoft make money out of the consumers for subscriptions and companies for sponsored ads that the provider is paying them for. And seeing this just reminds me of 2013.
"TV, TV, TV, Sports, Sports, Sports, Ad's, Ads', Ad's,... And then some games. Maybe" 🫤
To me, it doesn’t really matter. Ads suck but they ultimately make stuff cheaper
Use adguard DNS. That space is then blank whenever an ad is supposed to be there. Windows Central has an article on how to use their DNS on Xbox.
Xbox is going down the toilet over the past year. Just sad.
Gaming ads on the dash I can tolerate (just). Gaming ads on boot up hate, but this is nasty.
Removed - disrespecting others
@user0 That was already a thing in an old SmackDown vs. Raw game. 2010 maybe? When the match started online, a little display card would pop up emulating the real show with "Sponsored by: X" with a logo of some brand. It changed every so often, so it was updated regularly.
And we know the dire 360 dashboard. It was not acceptable back then, certainly isn't now. ESPECIALLY if they show it to paying subscribers. Disgusting.
@Mustoe
I think @PassePartout may be highlighting that more negative Xbox articles seem to appear on PushSquare than on here.
A few months ago, there was Specsavers. I haven't used an xbox since then, so not sure what other ads were showing up.
@Mustoe I disagree. The framing of your original post is that xbox is the bad choice, the really bad choice, the only logical way to read it is that the other choice(s) of consoles are much better.
There's arguments to be made for which one is the better/worse purchase, and there's plenty to say about what's wrong with Xbox, but the implication of that original post is that people would be much better off with a PS or Switch than an Xbox, and for a variety of reasons with those two that's also not automatically true.
In reality the state of consoles, and more accurately everything to do with gaming is heading down a deep, dark hole, maybe since the rice of mobile gamblegaming, and we'd all really be better off knitting.
When it was announced that MS would start putting yet more ads on the XBox, which I paid for and didn't have ads when I bought it, I thought great. Most of the ads are for selling GP, which I'm not buying, or games that MS can make money off of, undoubtedly by making a deal with the publisher such that they get "free" ads to users.
But what really annoyed me to the point I rarely use my XBox anymore is when they added full page ads. Now the marketing was "it only happens when you start your Xbox" but that was a lie. It happens when you resume your XBox as well. Since I let my XBox go to sleep when I'm not using it, you know to stop wasting power, I get it whenever I return to my Xbox to play it. Every single time. What's even worse is that MS is now recommending that you change your power save mode on XBox to "save the power" which will also trigger the full page ads even more. It is clear that MS doesn't feel they are getting enough money from XBox and GP subscriptions such that ads are the only way to continue to make money.
PS isn't this bad yet. They advertise their PS+ stuff right now. But I suspect Xbox is a glimpse at the future of PS and most likely Switch. Heck even Windows is doing this crap now...
They were advertising ‘Arkham Knight’ and ‘Destiny’, which you can't even buy on the Japanese dashboard.
If you select them from the dashboard, you get an error that they don't appear on the store page.
Of course, the problem is that they're not sold in Japan, but it's better than that, right?
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...