The big release of this week is undoubtedly Dying Light 2: Stay Human, which arrives a whole seven years after the original Dying Light, so it's safe to say we've been waiting a while!
Ahead of its launch on February 4th, the first reviews have been dropping today (including here at Pure Xbox), giving the wider public a taste of what to expect when it lands through their letterboxes on Friday.
So, without further ado, here's what the critics are saying so far:
Game Informer - (9.5/10)
"Dying Light 2 is an engaging journey of discovery and gaining power. Almost everything you do embraces those dynamics. In evolving beyond the first game's offerings, putting a stronger emphasis on the characters helps shape the world in meaningful ways... I adored almost every second of this game and see myself often revisiting it, as Techland has announced at least five years of DLC is on the way."
VG247 - (8/10)
"Dying Light 2 is messy and uneven. It’s also unique, exhilarating, and just plain fun to play, with one of the best settings in recent memory – despite the nagging feeling that the game could, and should, be more than what it is."
Windows Central - (4/5)
"Dying Light 2 truly shines with its high-stakes nighttime gameplay, which turns the modern and tired open-world formula on its head. While some of the writing isn't the best and next-gen console performance is a bit disappointing, Dying Light 2 offers a tight experience that builds on the original."
Push Square - (7/10)
"Dying Light 2 is a super solid follow-up to the 2015 original, building upon its fantastic gameplay loop with new traversal options for even more parkour fun. It's extremely disappointing, however, that the narrative and open world promises Techland made in the lead up to launch haven't been realised. Your choices don't have nearly as much impact as we would like, and the map is much more rigid than pre-release footage would have you believe. Still, Dying Light 2 feels awesome and empowering to play, and that can go a long way."
GameSpot - (6/10)
"Dying Light 2 is a perplexing game. Its story and characters are headache-inducing, and it appears to lack polish in many areas. But even a dozen hours after I rolled credits, I've found myself going back to the game to do another parkour challenge, rummage through another abandoned science lab, or just see if I can get from Point A to Point B without ever hitting the ground."
Pure Xbox - (5/10)
"With a lacklustre campaign that offers little to enjoy in the way of drama, some serious performance issues - which we hope will be patched day one - and an enormous world stuffed full of basic busywork padding, this is one zombie apocalypse we're finding quite hard to recommend."
The Guardian - (2/5)
"If all you want is a gigantic zombie-filled Skinner box crammed with loot and repetitive, incremental violence, Dying Light 2 absolutely works. Honestly, you’ll love it. You can explore and level up and get into fights using increasingly powerful weapons, and the interlocking compulsion loops do their job of settling you into that grind. But oh for a moment of genuine surprise, a truly memorable line of dialogue, a spark of mechanical invention."
So, as you can see, it's very much a mixed bag in terms of the reviews, and we happen to fall on the lower end of the scale here at Pure Xbox. Hey, everyone has different opinions! In terms of the Metacritic score, Dying Light 2 has a 77 based on 18 reviews for Xbox Series X at the time of writing, and a 78 based on 28 reviews for the PlayStation 5.
Will you be diving into Dying Light 2 later this week? Let us know in the comments.
Comments 23
geez the reviews are ALL OVER THE PLACE lol. i'll have to wait for a sale maybe.
WOW! I've never seen such a spread before!
Tl;dr..
..it sounds like if you wanted more dying light, then that's what you got, in spades. If you wanted something more, something evolved from the previous game, then you're left wanting.
@PhhhCough which normally would be fine, but here its a shame because they were making some hefty promises that aren't being delivered on.
That's all over the place.
yeah but the worst score comes from that well respected video games bible "The Guardian" so wouldn't put much stock in that score.
I got to give respect to anyone giving it a high/low score. Takes guts. I'll wait on this one.
This is why I don’t read reviews. The first Dying Light also received very mixed reviews, sitting at an aggregate score of 74 on Metacritic (I’m only referencing it to make a point, as I don’t see the value in it). At the time, I passed on it because of the reviews and when I finally played it for myself, I couldn’t believe how much I disagreed with what I had read. It’s one of my favorite games now and I still enjoy it. I think this is probably the case with this game as well, although I’ll make up my mind when I finally play it.
This the 1st game I’ve pre-ordered in 2 years. I hope I’m not disappointed.
Same happened to the first Dying Light when it came out. I remember the metacritic score was 74, but after the patches and with the release of the Following DLC it got a whopping 84 score. So let's hope that the same happens again with Dying Light 2. Either way, I've pre-ordered this one, I'll be the judge to that. ^^
@P3nguinprisM a good example of this is the PS5 game Days Gone. That was slated in a lot of reviews, i’d pre ordered it an the reviews dropped day before release. I played the game day 1 an it’s an incredible game. I think if ya liked the first one, which a lot did, you’ll like this.
@sjbsixpack Another great example.
From 95% at Game Informer down to 40% at the Guardian?
Wow that really is a wide spread of scores.
Review's are the same as the original mixed and the game became a cult classic
This proves that reviews are pointless but I still like reading some to know what certain games are about and technical details.
Honestly, I feel like I’ll save this one for later in the year if there’s a decent sale and the release catalog slows down. Seems like there’s a fair amount of bugs in it, but it sounds like there’s a fun gameplay loop too. I’m still cautiously interested.
Kinda sad to see pure xbox's thoughts are most closely aligned to the guardians, good way to lose credibility fast guys...
This site gave battlefield 2042 & call of duty vanguard a 7/10...
Well now I still have no idea if it's worth giving it a shot. Awesome...
@Gr81 love the avatar!
@MetalGear_Yoshi ty!
Same scores as the first game, I loved it, similar scores as that game Generation Zero got, I loved they too. And I've loved other games ridiculed by 'reviews' before too. So it's always a case of play the game or watch video gameplays if it yourself and make your own mind up.
Likewise I've hated or found boring games praised from the rafters by reviewers, like God If War, I much preferred the old ones that were over the top viewpoints.
@P3nguinprisM exactly I passed on it for the same reasons then purchased it at some gamestop sale and loved it it is really good. I think this article has made me decide to stick with my preorder and try it out.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...