Microsoft's Bill Stillwell, who previously worked on the backwards compatibility team at Xbox, talked recently with YouTube channel Dealer Gaming about the challenges faced in building the program for Xbox One, and how some developers weren't necessarily keen on the idea:
"When we first started the program, developers were really nervous, like 'do not change my game'. We even got to a point in emulation where games that had bugs - we needed to make sure that the bug reproduced in the emulator the same way that it did in the game. And not only could we not fix the bugs, the problem we would run into was, one particular game - the bug was like, 1 out of every 100 times on the Xbox 360 version. And then, when we emulated it, we hit the bug every single time."
The Microsoft executive went on to note that when Xbox 360 games were enhanced to display at 4K via backwards compatibility, such as Halo 3 and Red Dead Redemption, it proved a turning point for the program in terms of gathering support from the industry at large:
"And I think at that point, most of the industry made a switch and went - 'oh, why wouldn't I want my game to take advantage of HDR? Why wouldn't I want my game to look better?'... So, over time I think what you have to realise is the industry is reluctant to change, because they've got a model that works. And it takes, sort of, these seismic shifts in consumer behaviour before people say, 'oh, I guess it's OK for my back compat library to be available on the new console.'"
What are your thoughts on backwards compatibility on Xbox One? Tell us what you think the program below.
[source youtu.be, via tweaktown.com]
Comments 14
I'm all for authenticity, but not wanting bugs fixed seems a little overboard
I love backward-compatibility! I bought an Xbox one just for this! I can finally play lots of OG&360 games! it's like dream, I plan to buy them all!
I admit when I read the headline my first thought was that they were worried because it would mean it would make the idea of producing remasters that much more difficult to get away with. But after reading the article, I can kinda understand where the developers were coming from with fears about changing the game though bug fixing I’d have thought they’d be on board with.
I recently bought Lost Odyssey and Blue Dragon. I had the physical versions when they released back in the day but got rid of them somewhere down the road for for reason or another - don't remember why.
Xbox One backwards compatibility (especially on X) has revived those games - especially Blue Dragon. No more ridiculous slowdown, no more screen tear! It's like the games are finally running "as intended".
@GamingFan4Lyf yes, I have bought these two recently, I heard they run very well now!
Can't wait to try them, jrpg goodness!
I love old games, most of them are much better than modern ones, especially action games, more dynamics, narrative integrity and linearity to such games are only good. Backward compatibility is the best that Xbox offers. relieves to own different generations of consoles, besides, consoles break sooner or later, and it’s problematic to buy parts for them. and so having bought the new Xbox your collection of your favorite games is always with you.
I just love BC!! In fairness to us gamers, you don’t have to buy the game a second time unlike what Nintendo practices. I look forward to having my whole BC library available to me on the Xbox Series X!!!
@Crownhearts so true! I read that the original xbox has some components that fail after some years, regardless the system use! Pretty sad to be honest.
We are lucky to have BC!
Old is new again .I love playing old games again and experience new ones.
@XBontendo
I feel this is the same approach Capcom took with the Mega Man Legacy Collection. I would've been very happy if they had fixed the terrible flickering plaguing the originals, instead of console perfect ports.
I can understand not fixing some bugs. Sometimes bugs add some of the personality in a game, as long as it's not game breaking.
But I love love love backwards compatibility. I've had a few of my gamer friends all tell me Xbox doesn't have any exclusives but I've never understood that argument. Don't get me wrong, there are some great games on PS4, but I just don't feel jealous when I'm able to play the Final Fantasy XIII trilogy, every single Metal Gear Solid game except for 1 and 4, Silent Hill 2 and 3, Mass Effect trilogy, Prince of Persia (2008), Alice Madness Returns and on and on. Games that are impossible to play on PS4. And for gamers who missed out on last gen classics it's so incredible being able to see where a series starts, or to see how a franchise develops. Those games aren't left to memories or lets play on youtube.
And with former exclusives coming to Xbox like Kingdom Hearts, Final Fantasy X or Nier Automata, I've never been happier with being a gamer, or have felt like becoming a fan of a series has been more accessible.
It's convinced me to get a Series X.
They do seem 'nervous' about 'future' plans too - in particular Smart Delivery where you can buy a Game on XB1 and if/when you upgrade to Series X, you get the upgraded version without having to go out and buy a Series X version of that game.
BC has its downsides for devs and publishers - licensing issues, potential loss of sales for any remasters etc. Of course is better for the consumer and if Devs/publishers do want to try and make a quick buck with a Remaster, they can't just port the game and make a few tweaks to graphical settings - like raise the cap on the frame rate to 60fps, increase the output resolution to 4k, change a few settings from Medium to high/ultra etc and call it 'remastered'. They would have to do a bit more now....
@UnconfirmedBit Same here! I bought an Xbox One for backwards compatibility and now I enjoy a lot of old and new games on the same platform. It's a dream.
I like all the comments here appreciating backwards/forwards compatibility as much as I do.
One of the main reasons why I'm considering a Series X is the backwards compatibility. I haven't had an Xbox One, but would also enjoy playing my 360 and original games again.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...