Can it really be that time of the year again already?
Yes, friends, it's the end of another busy and rather tumultuous year for gaming, and mankind in general. There's been highs and lows, joys and sorrows, but we've just about made it through once again and, as usual, just a few weeks ago we asked you lovely lot to go ahead and vote for your favourite titles of 2021 in order for us to put together Pure Xbox's Game of the Year 2021 list.
We've now calculated and combined all of those votes using very special machines that reside deep within the bowels of Pure Xbox HQ, to come up with the definitive top ten which you can survey below.
So, are you ready to find out which title you've crowned as your Game of the Year for 2021? Go ahead and fix yourself a glass of something suitably seasonal, grab a comfy seat, get the tinfoil off that mince pie and let's jump in!
10. Control Ultimate Edition (Xbox Series X|S)
Yes, Remedy's Control, originally released all the way back in 2019, makes it into the number ten slot on our list this year thanks to its fancy pants next-gen Ultimate edition, which landed on Series X and S in February of this year.
Control Ultimate Edition takes what was already a thoroughly excellent game and irons out a handful of irritating technical issues that, on last-gen consoles, somewhat marred our time in the Oldest House. With spectacular ray-tracing, silky smooth framerates, enhanced graphics, an improved map, reworked checkpointing and all available DLC bundled in as well, this feels like Control how it was always meant to be experienced, and what an experience it is.
Remedy's game is a masterclass in cinematic atmosphere, in slowly and carefully layering combat complexity and flexibility, and in fully drawing you into its delightfully bizarre, Lynchian mystery world. Our time spent in the Oldest House, discovering Objects of Power, facing off against the Hiss in spectacular action sequences and enjoying all of the fantastic acting performances on offer, was one of our gaming highlights of the past few years and it was a delight to finally experience it all without the constant framerate issues of its original Xbox One version.
A bit of a surprise inclusion, perhaps, but Control Ultimate Edition is absolutely a worthy number ten on our GOTY list.
9. Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy (Xbox Series X|S)
After the fairly average effort that was Marvel's Avengers, we guess nobody was really expecting all that much from Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy, although with Eidos Montreal at the helm here we certainly hadn't lost all hope.
As it turned out, we needn't have worried, as what we've ended up with is a rip-roaring adventure that's packed full of hilarious banter between its band of misfit heroes - heroes that, for us, have never been more endearing - some wonderfully colourful and quirky alien worlds, and lots of proper, actual, you're going to make us cry emotion.
Yes, the gameplay is all pretty straightforward stuff that isn't gonna set the world on fire, but it's serviceable, it's fun, and it's bolstered to no end by the writing, world-building and absolutely gorgeous graphics on offer here. This really is one of the very best adventures we were taken on this year.
Please note that some external links on this page are affiliate links, which means if you click them and make a purchase we may receive a small percentage of the sale. Please read our FTC Disclosure for more information.
8. Mass Effect Legendary Edition (Xbox One)
Three of the most universally adored sci-fi epics ever made brought together in one huge and lovingly remastered package. It was hardly gonna end badly was it?
Mass Effect Legendary Edition was a dream come true for Mass Effect fans this year and a chance for us all to return to this wonderful world full of choice and consequence, dense and fascinating lore and, as the franchise progresses, some absolutely cracking combat sequences.
There are still a few rough edges here, we'll just never enjoy planet scanning or driving that infernal Mako, but overall this is one epic, emotionally charged sci-fi package and a long-awaited return to the Normandy that we hadn't even really realised we were so excited about. It was sure good to see you again, Shepard.
7. Hades (Xbox Series X|S)
Ah, Hades. What else is there left to say about Supergiant Games' superlative action roguelike?
With a hugely clever story setup that constantly develops and evolves as you take Zagreus deeper and deeper through the game's gloriously gaudy levels, and some of the very best action we've been treated to in this genre, Hades puts nary a foot wrong.
The virtual perfection on display here, the result of an extended and smartly used period of early access, is some of the deepest, most addictive gameplay you're likely to come across. With endless combat modifiers to encourage replayability, a fantastic contemporary reframing of Ancient Greek myths and characters, and the transformation of the roguelike genre's constant death into an addictive means of driving its narrative forward, this is one game we'll never get sick of playing.
As we said in our review:
"Hades knocks it out of the park, offering its stellar experience to Xbox players for the first time. It's every bit as incredible as it was a year ago, with punchy combat, an addictive gameplay loop and a cast of characters that prove to be charming and terrifying in the same breath."
6. Resident Evil Village (Xbox Series X|S)
Resident Evil 7's Ethan Winters returned in May for an adventure that saw a huge switch in tone from his blood-curdling gorefest of a debut outing. Resident Evil Village is, in comparison, a far more relaxed, knockabout affair that introduces busty vampire sirens, hordes of daft werewolves and one of the oddest shopkeepers you're ever likely to meet. The fun side of Resident Evil, the action-centric side of the series, is all back on the agenda here.
Yes, this one wears its Resident Evil 4 influences on its shredded sleeve too, with its Eastern European setting and the tone of its action all harking back to Leon Kennedy's superlative 2005 adventure. It's a good time overall, not without its rough edges and a few issues here and there, but we liked it plenty nevertheless, as we said in our review:
"Resident Evil Village may not quite live up to the highs of its terrifying predecessor but it's a still a solid entry in the long-running series that's well worth checking out. Eastern Europe makes for a fantastically atmospheric and surprisingly open setting here, it's chock full of delightfully oddball characters and features a handful of properly entertaining set-pieces to blast through."
Comments 41
My personal top 10 would be:
10. Unpacking
9. Hitman 3
8. Death's Door
7. Resident Evil Village
6. Blasphemous: Wounds of Eventide
5. Psychonauts 2
4. Hades
3. Forza Horizon 5
2. Halo Infinite
1. State of Decay 2.
Yes, I chose State of Decay 2 as my 2021 Game of the Year. I am aware that it was released on 2018, but this game has received so many major upgrades ever since - specially THIS YEAR - that now it is a completely new game. Call it State of Decay 2.5 if you will, but the fact is that no other game in 2021 has sucked more of my time and brought me as much joy as this game.
Oh my, Halo Infinite getting number one from PureXbox would definitely ruffle some very angry and obsessed feathers 🤣.
For me personally is between FH5, Psyconauts 2, Deaths Door and Halo Infinite. Just can not decide 😁. Regardless, it was a fantastic year for gaming, sans the next gen console shortages.
Really great year for game pass and Xbox. Seems to be setting up a great 2022 and beyond.
I have to agree, Halo is my GOTY. Yes I am a huge halo nerd but infinite has got me playing multiplayer again after a long time away playing single player games and having children. I am loving hopping online for a couple of games a night when the kids are asleep. Congratulations 343
The Gunk for me.
It wasn’t ‘the best’, but I really enjoyed exploring that magical little world.
A great year for Xbox gaming though all round as this list shows and there are a few I’ll be playing throughout 2022.
From someone who loves open world games I'm dissapointed that halo is at number 1, the open world part is so bland, also disappointed to not see tales of Arise in this list. And I would also include the Gunk as even though it was short I really enjoyed its charm.
My top 10 (won't include Playstation/Nintendo games)
1. Tales of Arise
2. Forza Horizon 5
3. The Gunk
4. Resident Evil Village
5. In sound Mind
6. Scarlet nexus
7. Guardians of the galaxy
8. Project zero maiden of Blackwater
9. Nier Replicant
10. Biomutant
Very happy to admit how wrong I was. From multiplayer to single player Halo Infinite is a superb game and a very deserving GOTY. (My pick is Horizon 5 but I'm arguing peanuts here. Halo, Forza and Psychonauts are all worthy winners)
I'm mostly playing old games as it's been my first year with Xbox. Infinite is absolutely amazing and I'd say it's going to take the cake for me but I'm actually putting Gamepass as my GOTY. It's really allowed me as a very casual gamer to just get exposed to so many different games and genres that i can tell you i wouldn't have ever even considered without the service.
Ori and the blind forest was fantastic as was Titanfall 2 camping... they both get you in the feels.
Great selection way better that nintendo life picks they live in a nostalgia trap and can’t seem to see better things than what Nintendo keep reselling them the same games over and over on different consloes.
@Sam_TSM in the same boat. Was disappointed with MANY aspects of Infinite and feel it lost too much going open world, yet the gunplay and grapple are truly magnificent. Plot, world, characters were not. Still was good in the most important areas
I enjoy the halo games but after hearing what they did with the story for this one I lost interest in playing it , Forza horizon 5 is the best Xbox release this year in my opinion
Halo Infinite is a very deserving Xbox GOTY. It’s absolutely fantastic. Just beat it two days ago and I loved every minute of it. There’s a few narrative caveats, in my opinion, but it’s so fun to play that I don’t mind so much. My ultimate GOTY is Metroid Dread, but Infinite came closer to it than I expected.
1. Metroid Dread
2. Halo Infinite
3. Resident Evil Village
4. The Forgotten City
5. Life is Strange: True Colors
6. Kena: Bridge of Spirits
7. Ratchet and Clank: Rift Apart
8. Psychonauts 2
9. Deathloop
10. Returnal
I go back and forth on if I should include Bowser’s Fury or not in my top 10 too. I wouldn’t include 3D World because, to me, it’s a years old game, but Bowser’s Fury is such a strange thing and I don’t know if it qualifies as a complete game. If I did count it, it’d be #6 or 7 and knock Returnal out of my list.
For me across all platforms (10 to 1);
Rift Apart
New Pokémon Snap
Eastward
Resident Evil Village
Deaths Door
Halo Infinite
Psychonauts 2
Metroid Dread
Skyward Sword HD
Little Nightmares 2
There simply was no other choice for number 1. I'm primarily a Playstation player but Halo Infinite not only made me not use my Playstation in a good long while, but reminded me of how much fun an FPS can be. Congrats to 343 and Microsoft for putting out a real gem this year!
@Would_you_kindly I’m super into the old halo stories (5 as the exception) and very much a classic halo gamer. I also, as a result, was slightly disappointed in the sort of hollow narrative feel I felt while playing through Infinite. However, if you enjoy Halo it is well worth a play through, and is tied with Psychonauts for my GOTY. It doesn’t feel like classic Halo in a lot of ways narratively, but it is its own new experience and is amazing for what it is. And the Halo gameplay is better than ever. Horizon 5 is definitely amazing though too so I’ll give that to you.
I'd still put Resident Evil: Village at the top but Halo Infinite is definitely a deserving winner. I liked, but didn't love 4, and then I pretty much couldn't stand 5 not only was the story terrible in the latter, and the characterization of Cortana disappointing but the gunplay sucked. With all of that I was concerned about Infinite but fortunately 343 made, easily, its best Halo to date and one of my new favorite in the series. The story wasn't perfect but trying to clean up the mess of 5 was always going to pose a problem, in that sense what we got was great, imo. But the most important part, the gameplay, 343 hit a home run. It felt like classic Halo, the grappleshot added a new spin to thinks and made traversal (even combat in some ways) extremely fun and the look and sound of classic Halo is also there. Couldn't have asked for a better comeback, looking forward to what the next few years will bring and how 343 will proceed with doing the single player campaigns.
Hmm couldn't disagree with that list more. Hades was infinitely better than Halo (see what I did there!) And I just don't get driving/flying games as they are so boring for me - but my top 10 would probably upset the masses so it's probably on point here for most.
@xMightyMatt14x I actually didn't hate 5's story was enjoying the whole cortana turning evil story line but heard that this one basically makes the ending of halo 5 pointless
I would have put tales of arise at 1 and lost judgement at 2. I haven't played any of those games on the list.
@Would_you_kindly I actually agree about the meta story of halo 5. I didn’t mind it. I just didn’t like only playing as chief for 3 missions.
But I wouldn’t say this makes it pointless. It actually does follow up on 5. The disappointment I felt was like never seeing important characters from 5, so where they are is still up in the air. But the Cortana thing actually wraps up well.
@xMightyMatt14x I'll probably still end up playing infinite eventually it just went from something I was really looking forward to to something I'll play when I get around to it
I don’t really care what the GOTY was. I’ve had more fun with my Xbox this year than I’ve had with any console in a long time. Halo is fun it’s definitely grabbed more now than it did for the first few hours. And Forza was fun. But the load times on One X are horrible so I really want to try it again when I get a series X. But having Game Pass and playing old stuff as well as new stuff all the time is just so much fun. I’ve even purchased some older games on the One X. With a GOTY top ten list like this I can’t wait to see the next four years for Xbox and just gaming in general. Nice work Team Xbox.
I love how basically every single game in this list could very easily be somebody’s #1 GOTY and I’d find no fault whatsoever in that opinion. Mine is Psychonauts 2, because that game was a LONG time coming and it’s amazing how well it turned out. Everything I wanted and expected it to be, and then some.
Nice list, PureXbox! I do want to reward the genuinely original, creative and mindblowing ideas and gameplay mechanics in my number #1, however.
10. Last Stop (interesting storylines intertwined)
9. Art of Rally (somehow very addictive)
8. The Artful Escape (almost gameplay-less fun)
7. Psychonauts 2 (just started playing!)
6. The Procession to Cavalry (point & click with great art style and bizarre situations)
5. Omno (laidback platformer with a heart)
4. The Gunk (lovely little adventure, plays greatly)
3. Forza Horizon 5
2. Halo Infinite
1. It Takes Two (mindblowing creative - plays some parts in pure awe)
Four of the ten are Microsoft studios games too.
A great year for the Xbox division.
State of Decay 2 on Series X/S is certainly an awesome updated game (something that Nintendo would have re-released full-priced). This was the discovery of the year for me and one of the games I've enjoyed the most.
Hades has a nice style and the graphics and gameplay suit the bigger screen better (compared to the original launch on Switch, yes you can connect it to the TV unless it's the Lite which is the model I have). I haven't beaten Hades yet but I have played many hours and I can't consider it a game of the year candidate. The story and characters are all good but the main ingredient is the gameplay and it's a dungeon crawler game, not my favourite genre. I appreciate the game and it can be considered educational in some sense but it can't be in my list. I consider Maiden of Black Water a better candidate because of the same reason, the genre. Flight Simulator is a good candidate because it pushes the boundaries like any other game on any console and it's perfect in its own way. Resident Evil VIII is another good candidate, obviously. I can't wait to play more Resident Evil games like Code Veronica remake and to see what direction IX goes, hopefully it's more like the classic games and less a gore fest like VII.
There are some games I haven't played like Control, Guardians of the Galaxy, Mass Effect, It Takes Two, Tales of Arise and Psychonauts 2 but I'll play all of them someday. Both Forza Horizon 5 and Halo Infinite deserved to be on top. Halo Infinite, after a bit of development hell, has been saved with external help and extra development time, which makes me believe something's wrong at 343 Industries. I'm happy that I was right about it when I said earlier this year that it would be great. It and Master Chief Collection have received tons of improvements, they both are responsible for the rebirth of Halo and that's cause of celebration and winning on this site is poetic.
Nice to see Control on here. It's a masterpiece, and is often overlooked.
Unpopular opinion, but I wouldn't have included Forza 5 or Halo Infinite. Neither were as good as I hoped, but I tend to be in a minority when it comes to gaming.
As someone who prefers to play local splitscreen with friends/family over online, it feels like Halo Infinite and 343 are getting a huge pass here both from Pure XBox as well as many/most commenters. After a full year's delay in launching the game, it still won't have splitscreen multiplayer, co-op, or the Forge for several more months at least. A whole slew of content for the campaign was also apparently left on the cutting room floor, including stuff like varied environments that even the very first Halo managed to pull off; as one reviewer put it, it feels like the entirety of Halo Infinite is trying to emulate Silent Cartographer. Oh, but 343 made sure to have thousands of $$$ worth of skins (and cat ears) ready to monetize a basically 70 percent complete game. COVID can only take the blame for so much; it's all about priorities, folks.
Now, I won't argue that what's there is excellent, and if it satisfies your needs/wants as a player, then so be it. And while they have a ways to go (the ability to use and man vehicles/mounted weapons, not to mention actually know what to do in CTF, would be a huge evolution), the bots are a GREAT step forward for those of us who are less than enamored with online and the negative things that tend to come with it. But too many companies are being rewarded for giving us less and less at the original point-of-sale anymore, to the point we're often getting glorified betas for our $60. That's a practice that doesn't deserve accolades and encouragement.
@Magabro
Glad to hear this about State of Decay. One of the games that interests me very much as someone that didn't have a Xbox One, and is still waiting on a Series X.
@Akimi It's very addictive, it's like a survival simulator with the right balance of freedom and complexity and it runs and looks like a dream on Series X. It's one of those game I didn't realise I had spent so much time and when you finish the first community story you just want to get back (with extra boons and selecting some of the same survivors).
@BlueOcean
Sounds great. Do you think the first one is worth going back to? Or just jump right into the second one?
@Akimi I had the same question this year. I tried the first one but it's not worth it because it still runs poorly even on Series X and its map is included in the sequel so jump right into the second one that includes the first game's map, more features and much better graphics and performance.
Great list, I really need to get around to play GOTG..
@BlueOcean
Great info, thanks. Happy new year.
@Akimi Same from me😊.
As someone who’s completed Control on Xbox One, would anyone recommend the Ultimate Series X version for a second play through with the graphical upgrade and DLC?
I mostly agree with PX’s list, especially Halo Infinite taking the number 1 spot. A great game that was worth the wait.
@BlueOcean @Akimi it's nice to see State of Decay 2 getting some love, it certainly deserves it!
I agree with Banjo, the first one runs poorly and you'd better jump straight to the sequel.
That's a great idea, actually, calling me Banjo 😊... or Banjo- because Banjo is not available.
@Banjo- 😆
Just don't expect me to change my username to Raz!
@Magabro
Razputin?
@Magabro Ha ha! OK but it would be cool!
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...